cpan-testers-discuss  

Re: PM post on Makefile.PL FAIL for missing libraries

Sisyphus
Thu, 27 Sep 2007 05:34:47 -0700


----- Original Message ----- From: "David Golden" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
.
.

At least for CPAN -- I think this is as simple as just *exiting* from
a Makefile.PL with an exit value of 0.  CPAN::Reporter considers that
"success" and does not issue a FAIL report, but then CPAN.pm notices
that no Makefile was created and refuses to continue into make or test
phases.

I just released CPAN-Test-Dummy-Perl5-Make-PLExit to CPAN to confirm
this behavior.  if CPANPLUS has similar behavior to
CPAN/CPAN::Reporter, then when the smokers get it, I shouldn't see any
test reports for it at all.

I don't know whether you're getting reports or not, but at
http://search.cpan.org/~dagolden/CPAN-Test-Dummy-Perl5-Make-PLExit-1.00/
there are already 6 "FAIL" reports.

Whether they'll ever be viewable via the "View" link on that page is also problematical. At the time I uploaded Math::MPC, I also uploaded a new version of Math::GMPq (version 0.11). There are a couple of "genuine" FAILures with that module, and those FAILures have been viewable from the "View" link at http://search.cpan.org/~sisyphus/Math-GMPq-0.11/ for a few days now. However the "View" link at
http://search.cpan.org/~sisyphus/Math-MPC-0.45/ still reveals nothing.

Cheers,
Rob