Wolfgang Zekoll
Thu, 5 Feb 2004 23:22:00 +0100
<x-flowed> At 21:06 05.02.2004, you wrote: >Thank you for your reply and I hope this helps. Yes, this is whatI call debugging information. >/var/log/messages on the proxy server > >Feb 5 15:01:26 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[32483]: connected to client: >snoopy.mvnhealth.com, interface= 172.19.11.12:21 >Feb 5 15:01:26 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[32483]: info: monitor mode: on, ccp: ><unset> >Feb 5 15:01:26 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[32483]: -ERR: missing hostname The proxy server says that you are not supplying the target's FTP-server name with the username. It expects [EMAIL PROTECTED]' but you're sending only `login'. >... ># Types of firewalls: ># ------------------ ># ># type 1: Connect to firewall host, but send "USER [EMAIL PROTECTED]" ># >... >firewall-type=3 ># This is wrong, must be `1'. Regards Wolfgang Zekoll --general-l------------------------------------ To unsubscribe please visit: http://www.ftpproxy.org/html/maillinglists.html </x-flowed> From [EMAIL PROTECTED] Fri Feb 06 15:43:23 2004 Return-Path: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Received: from mail.compucation.de (mail.compucation.de [213.185.64.44]) by um1.pce.de (8.11.3/8.11.3/SuSE Linux 8.11.1-0.5) with ESMTP id i16EZGw12618 (using TLSv1/SSLv3 with cipher RC4-MD5 (128 bits) verified NO) for <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; Fri, 6 Feb 2004 15:35:17 +0100 Received: from mail.mvnhealth.com ([64.9.116.126]) by compucation.de (mail.compucation.de [213.185.64.44]) (MDaemon.PRO.v6.8.5.R) with ESMTP id 49-md50000000009.tmp for <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; Fri, 06 Feb 2004 15:34:26 +0100 Message-ID: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> X-Mailer: Novell GroupWise 5.5.5 Date: Fri, 06 Feb 2004 09:33:30 -0500 From: "Scott Kern" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "general-l List Member" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: [general-l] ftp.proxy and ncftp {05} Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Disposition: inline X-Guinevere: 2.0.12 ; Faxton St Lukes Heal X-MDRemoteIP: 64.9.116.126 Sender: [EMAIL PROTECTED] X-Return-Path: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Precedence: bulk List-Unsubscribe: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> X-MDMailing-List: [EMAIL PROTECTED] X-MDSend-Notifications-To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Reply-To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] X-MDaemon-Deliver-To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit X-MIME-Autoconverted: from quoted-printable to 8bit by um1.pce.de id i16EZGw12618 X-UIDL: (dW"[EMAIL PROTECTED]"!^=-"!2-h!! X-Eudora2Unix: 3905-11-05T08:39:36Z converted I changed the firewall setting in ncftp's firewall file from 3 to 1. Now the problem is passing the password, in this case my email address, since I'm going to an anonymous ftp site. How do I pass the password. Below is the output from both ftp.proxy and ncftp. My ultimate goal is to set up a ftp proxy for my comapny, that first, verifies the user is a member of a certain NT domain group, then uses the user's NT doamin username and password for authentication to allow the user through the ftp proxy server. The proxy server is also running squid and I had to write a script to do the same type of authentication. I've read all the documentation on your website, except rfc 959 and 2389, but obviously I'm fully comprehending it. Thank you very much for your help. debug stuff Command line: ncftp [EMAIL PROTECTED] Output from /var/log/message on proxy server Feb 6 09:00:37 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[839]: connected to client: snoopy.mvnhealth. com, interface= 172.19.11.12:21 Feb 6 09:00:37 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[839]: info: monitor mode: on, ccp: <unset> Feb 6 09:00:38 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[839]: connected to server: ftp.cse.buffalo.e du Feb 6 09:00:43 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[839]: -ERR: reply to PASS: 530 Login incorre ct. Feb 6 09:01:04 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[843]: connected to client: snoopy.mvnhealth. com, interface= 172.19.11.12:21 Feb 6 09:01:04 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[843]: info: monitor mode: on, ccp: <unset> Feb 6 09:01:04 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[843]: connected to server: ftp.cse.buffalo.e du Feb 6 09:01:07 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[843]: -ERR: reply to PASS: 530 Login incorre ct. Output from ncftp SESSION STARTED at: Fri Feb 6 09:00:37 2004 Program Version: NcFTP 3.1.5/066 Oct 13 2002, 09:25 PM Library Version: LibNcFTP 3.1.5 (October 13, 2002) Process ID: 7094 Platform: linux-x86 Hostname: localhost.localdomain (rc=4) Terminal: screen 09:00:37 Fw: 172.19.11.12 Type: 1 User: skern Pass: (none) Port: 21 09:00:37 FwExceptions: .localdomain,localdomain 09:00:37 Connecting to [EMAIL PROTECTED] via 172.19.11.12... 09:00:37 Fw: 172.19.11.12 Type: 1 User: skern Pass: (none) Port: 21 09:00:37 FwExceptions: .localdomain,localdomain 09:00:37 LibNcFTP 3.1.5 (October 13, 2002) compiled for linux-x86 09:00:37 Uname: Linux|snoopy|2.4.20-28.9|#1 Thu Dec 18 13:45:22 EST 2003|i686 09:00:37 Glibc: 2.3.2 (stable) 09:00:37 Logging in... 09:00:37 220: server ready - login please 09:00:37 Connected to [EMAIL PROTECTED] 09:00:37 Cmd: USER [EMAIL PROTECTED]@ftp.cse.buffalo.edu 09:00:37 331: password required 09:00:37 Cmd: PASS xxxxxxxx 09:00:43 530: bad login 09:00:43 Cmd: QUIT 09:00:43 Sleeping 20 seconds. 09:00:43 Sleeping 20 seconds... 09:01:03 Retry Number: 1 09:01:03 Redialing (try 1)... 09:01:04 Logging in... 09:01:04 220: server ready - login please 09:01:04 Connected to [EMAIL PROTECTED] 09:01:04 Cmd: USER [EMAIL PROTECTED]@ftp.cse.buffalo.edu 09:01:04 331: password required 09:01:04 Cmd: PASS xxxxxxxx 09:01:07 530: bad login 09:01:07 Cmd: QUIT 09:01:07 Sleeping 20 seconds. 09:01:07 Sleeping 20 seconds... --------------------------------------------- Command line: ncftp ftp.cse.buffalo.edu Output from /var/log/message on proxy server Feb 6 09:13:49 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[924]: connected to client: snoopy.mvnhealth. com, interface= 172.19.11.12:21 Feb 6 09:13:49 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[924]: info: monitor mode: on, ccp: <unset> Feb 6 09:13:49 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[924]: connected to server: ftp.cse.buffalo.e du Feb 6 09:13:53 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[924]: -ERR: reply to PASS: 530 Login incorre ct. Feb 6 09:14:14 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[925]: connected to client: snoopy.mvnhealth. com, interface= 172.19.11.12:21 Feb 6 09:14:14 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[925]: info: monitor mode: on, ccp: <unset> Feb 6 09:14:14 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[925]: connected to server: ftp.cse.buffalo.e du Feb 6 09:14:18 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[925]: -ERR: reply to PASS: 530 Login incorre ct. Output from ncftp SESSION STARTED at: Fri Feb 6 09:13:49 2004 Program Version: NcFTP 3.1.5/066 Oct 13 2002, 09:25 PM Library Version: LibNcFTP 3.1.5 (October 13, 2002) Process ID: 7146 Platform: linux-x86 Hostname: localhost.localdomain (rc=4) Terminal: xterm 09:13:49 Fw: 172.19.11.12 Type: 1 User: skern Pass: (none) Port: 21 09:13:49 FwExceptions: .localdomain,localdomain 09:13:49 Connecting to ftp.cse.buffalo.edu via 172.19.11.12... 09:13:49 Fw: 172.19.11.12 Type: 1 User: skern Pass: (none) Port: 21 09:13:49 FwExceptions: .localdomain,localdomain 09:13:49 LibNcFTP 3.1.5 (October 13, 2002) compiled for linux-x86 09:13:49 Uname: Linux|snoopy|2.4.20-28.9|#1 Thu Dec 18 13:45:22 EST 2003|i686 09:13:49 Glibc: 2.3.2 (stable) 09:13:49 Logging in... 09:13:49 220: server ready - login please 09:13:49 Connected to ftp.cse.buffalo.edu. 09:13:49 Cmd: USER [EMAIL PROTECTED] 09:13:49 331: password required 09:13:49 Cmd: PASS xxxxxxxx 09:13:53 530: bad login 09:13:53 Cmd: QUIT 09:13:53 Sleeping 20 seconds. 09:13:53 Sleeping 20 seconds... 09:14:13 Retry Number: 1 09:14:13 Redialing (try 1)... 09:14:14 Logging in... 09:14:14 220: server ready - login please 09:14:14 Connected to ftp.cse.buffalo.edu. 09:14:14 Cmd: USER [EMAIL PROTECTED] 09:14:14 331: password required 09:14:14 Cmd: PASS xxxxxxxx 09:14:18 530: bad login 09:14:18 Cmd: QUIT 09:14:18 Sleeping 20 seconds. 09:14:18 Sleeping 20 seconds... Scott Kern UNIX System Administrator Network Data Systems, LLC (315) 624-5879 >>> [EMAIL PROTECTED] 02/05/04 05:20PM >>> At 21:06 05.02.2004, you wrote: >Thank you for your reply and I hope this helps. Yes, this is whatI call debugging information. >/var/log/messages on the proxy server > >Feb 5 15:01:26 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[32483]: connected to client: >snoopy.mvnhealth.com, interface= 172.19.11.12:21 >Feb 5 15:01:26 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[32483]: info: monitor mode: on, ccp: ><unset> >Feb 5 15:01:26 proxy1-lx ftp.proxy[32483]: -ERR: missing hostname The proxy server says that you are not supplying the target's FTP-server name with the username. It expects [EMAIL PROTECTED]' but you're sending only `login'. >... ># Types of firewalls: ># ------------------ ># ># type 1: Connect to firewall host, but send "USER [EMAIL PROTECTED]" ># >... >firewall-type=3 ># This is wrong, must be `1'. Regards Wolfgang Zekoll --general-l------------------------------------ To unsubscribe please visit: http://www.ftpproxy.org/html/maillinglists.html CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This e-mail message, including any attachments, is for the sole use of the intended recipients(s) and may contain confidential and privileged information. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure, or distribution is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient(s), please contact the sender by return e-mail and destroy all copies of the original message. Thank you. --general-l------------------------------------ To unsubscribe please visit: http://www.ftpproxy.org/html/maillinglists.html