Thanks again. Yes. Madeleine was born in late May of 1888, so there are  
some limitations with these stories.
  It does seem as if some of these accounts (of recording crying  babies) 
have been, shall we say, "conflated." By the time of Miller's book  on Edison 
(1931), the general version had been moved back to the era of the  first 
(tinfoil) phonograph and utilizing Edison's first son Tom jr. (born  Jan 
1876). That is the account preferred by the 1940 film ('Edison the  Man').
It would be helpful if we could find out if the crying child/tinfoil  had 
any historical roots, or at least when it was first told as such (i.e. how  
soon after 1878).
 Certainly by May 1894, in popular phonograph exhibitions, there  was 
already a niche for a crying baby (and sometimes a soothing mother). And  even 
some attempts to present Pres Cleveland's out of wedlock "baby"  (crying) on a 
 Shall I/we assume that Gouraud's version in 1888 of a crying baby was  
apparently anonymous (or just not identified)?
In a message dated 4/20/2016 6:48:01 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time, writes:

Gouraud did exhibit it (baby crying) there, as reported in the  local press 
that July (1888).  He doesn't seem to have identified it as a  record of 
Edison's own daughter, though.

Phono-L mailing list

Reply via email to