Re: Could pig dynamic change the reduce number according the mapper task number ?

[Benjamin Reed]

actually i believe that the same conf object that goes to the 
InputFormat is also the one that gets sent to the jobtracker, so if we 
update the reducers in that conf object it should also change the number 
of reduces that get sent to the jobtracker.

ben

Alan Gates wrote:
I agree that it would be very useful to have a dynamic number of  
reducers.  However, I'm not sure how to accomplish it.  MapReduce  
requires that we set the number of reducers up front in JobConf, when  
we submit the job.  But we don't know the number of maps until  
getSplits is called after job submission.  I don't think MR will allow  
us to set the number of reducers once the job is started.

Others have suggested that we use the file size to specify the number  
of reducers.  We cannot always assume the inputs are HDFS files (it  
could be from HBase or something).  Also different storage formats  
(text, sequence files, zebra) would need different ratios of bytes to  
reducers since they store data at different compression rates.  Maybe  
this could still work assuming, only in the HDFS case, with the  
assumption that the user understands the compression ratios and thus  
can set the reducer input accordingly.  But I'm not sure this will be  
simple enough to be useful.

Thoughts?

Alan.


On Nov 12, 2009, at 12:12 AM, Jeff Zhang wrote:

  
Hi all,

Often, I will run one script on different data set. Sometimes small  
data set
and sometimes large data set. And different size of data set require
different number of reducers.
I know that the default reduce number is 1, and users can change the  
reduce
number in script by keywords parallel.

But I do not want to be bothered to change reduce number in script  
each time
I run script.
So I have an idea that could pig provide some API that users can set  
the
ratio between map task and reduce task. (and some new keyword in pig  
latin
to set the ratio)

e.g. If I set the ratio to be 2:1, then if I have 100 map tasks, it  
will
have 50 reduce task accordingly.

I think it will be convenient for pig users.


Jeff Zhang