rda-l  

[RDA-L] Feedback on RDA

Mills, Deborah
Mon, 30 Aug 2010 12:30:35 -0700

Hi everyone. This is my first time posting to the list, which I joined a couple 
of weeks ago.

Like many of you, I am struggling to wrap my head around RDA and the toolkit. 
What surprises me is the speed at which it seems to be going through: I haven't 
seen any mention from the powers that be about taking any length of time to 
gather and process feedback after the 2 month preview, and perhaps tweak either 
RDA or the toolkit to reflect changes suggested by users, or things that have 
been flagged that just won't work.

I agree with a previous poster about the convoluted language being imposed, and 
am dismayed by the response from one of the RDA authors that it is aimed at 
those outside the library world. Firstly, I can't see that the language will be 
any more comprehensible to a non-library trained person, and secondly, if there 
is so much difference to the language used depending on the user of RDA, why 
not have different versions, aimed at different users?

Deborah Mills 
Cataloguer 

E.P. Taylor Research Library 
Art Gallery of Ontario 
317 Dundas Street West 
Toronto, Ontario  
Canada   M5T 1G4
 
e-mail: deborah_mi...@ago.net 
ph: 416-979-6660 ext. 390 
fax: 416-979-6602