Allen Gilliland wrote: > I think you pasted the wrong url. It should be ... > > http://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/ROLLER/Proposal_FeedHistory
oops.. > > I am basically +0 on this proposal and could be swayed either way. I > don't have any particular problems with it other than the fact that it's > a draft and I'm not particularly keen to put implementations of draft > specs into a solid product. That can be overcome with Dave's earlier > suggestion though, which is that if we do this it should be 1) > toggleable via the config file and 2) disabled by default. So this is a > prerequisite for me until the spec goes final. Feed history is a draft, but those link/@rel (first, next, previous, last) are baked really hard into APP. As a matter of fact is also already in our code for Atom Protocol written by Dave. Link relationships in Atom are nice because they are not intrusive at all. It's something that can be ignored if not understood very easily, so it shouldn't be a big deal if we turn it on. In the case that the spec falls through, we remove it. I think Roller has way too many options. When in doubt, search for RollerConfig.getProperty() in the code to see if there's an option for what I want. > > My other hangup is more of a generalized sense that this is > functionality that could be better supported via a web service than > feeds. Part of me feels that feeds are ephemeral and designed to be > just a summary by design and this changes the nature of that, but I > could be persuaded otherwise. whoa.. do I see a REST vs WS* argument brewing? :D /[handle]/feeds/atom?page=1 is a web service. If feeds were ephemeral, APP would have no hope of becoming the standard and de-facto API for read-write web. -Elias > > -- Allen > > > Elias Torres wrote: >> Hi everyone, >> >> I just posted the (very simple) feed history to the wiki: >> >> http://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/ROLLER/Roller+Proposals >> >> Please comment on it and give me a thumbs up with a pointer where I can >> commit this work to (is it trunk or 4.0 branch)? >> >> -Elias >
