Re: Re: Malthus revisited (fwd)
At 08:07 AM 28/06/00 -0400, Louis wrote: >Can the capitalist system resolve these [ecological] problems? This is a >theoretical >question that has challenged a wide variety of thinkers. David Harvey's new >book "Justice, Nature, and the Geography of Difference" argues that it can. Harvey does NOT argue capitalism can resolve ecological problems. Did you read the book? Bill Burgrss
Re: Re: Malthus revisited (fwd)
Mine: >Lou, I agree with the rest of your post. I should, however, open a small >paranthesis that I don't frankly think that comrade Mark has Marx's >critique of Malthus in his mind when he defends Bartlett, since Bartlett, >is not a Marxist. The problem is that most, if not all, of the empirical research being done on dwindling resources and irrational use of those that remain is by neo-Malthusians of one sort or another. For example, the Worldwatch Institute is the premier think-tank for producing facts about various aspects of the ecosphere. It is run by Lester Brown, an advocate of closed borders, who is "not one of us". By the same token, it is utterly necessary for ecosocialists to be engaged with their research: I especially recommend the Worldwatch Institute 1998 edition of the "State of the World: a Report on Progress Toward a Sustainable Society." The Institute is a mainstream environmentalist organization that gets funding from the Rockefeller Foundation and Pew Charitable Trust. The executive director is Lester R. Brown, who has held posts at the UN and the Department of Agriculture. The best way to describe the report is as an expert, high-level briefing on capitalism's ecological contradictions. It proposes solutions that fall squarely within the capitalist system. For those of us who believe that these contradictions can only be resolved through a socialist transformation, the information is particularly valuable. Proof that the ruling class wanted the straight poop from the Worldwatch Institute researchers can be found in the radical credentials of a few of them, including Michael Klare, a frequent contributor to the Nation magazine and Phyllis Bennis, Pacifica's UN reporter and an ex-leader of a defunct Maoist group called Line of March. I found two items of particular interest. One deals with declining fish stocks. The other deals with water pollution produced by the modern capital-intensive livestock industry. Although the report does not come out and say it, the only conclusion one can draw is that these problems are rooted in the anarchy of the capitalist mode of production itself. The report states that according to the Food and Agriculture Administration (FAO), a US agency, the present capacity of the world's fishing fleets is 200% of the world's available fisheries. Over the past 50 years, technological breakthroughs in the fishing industry have far exceeded nature's ability to reproduce itself. The biggest change has been the introduction of sonar, a wartime innovation. Many of the first new fishing trawlers were actually converted WWII submarine hunters. In the early 1950s, new ships were built from the ground up that could catch 500 tons of fish a day. Huge trawl nets brought the catch on the deck and dumped it into onboard processing and freezing facilities. In the past, ships had to return to port quickly before the fish spoiled. Now equipped with freezers they could spend months at sea, sweeping up vast quantities of fish. They roamed the planet in search of profits. In 1970 the tonnage of all fishing boats was 13,616. In 1992 it was 25,994, a 91% increase. Capital simply flowed to the profitable fishing industry with little regard to the long-term consequences. One of the consequences of the industrial trawling model is that large-scale production techniques generate huge amounts of waste. The nets draw unwanted species that are simply discarded. The FAO estimates that discarded fish total 27 million tons each year, about 1/3 of the total catch. This includes sea mammals, seabirds and turtles. While Greenpeace activists fight for the life of the unfortunate porpoise, many other species are disappearing without fanfare. The loss is serious since all of these species interact with each other in the marine ecosystem and make natural reproduction possible. A similar sort of contradiction occurs in the livestock industry where technological breakthroughs accelerate production but at huge and possibly fatal costs to the environment. The Worldwatch Institute identifies fertilizer and cheap transportation as the main culprits. Cheap transportation makes it possible to separate the ranch and the feed supply from each other across huge distances, even overseas. This means that while it can be profitable to locate a cattle ranch, poultry or hog farm near large metropolitan markets, the organic waste the animals produce is not easily recyclable. Most of these animals are not raised on the open range, but in huge buildings where excreta flows from the pens into drains that lead to rivers or underground water supplies. In Europe, for example, the livestock industry purchases feed from Brazil, Thailand or the USA. But the industry has outgrown the capacity of nearby lands to absorb the manure. The Netherlands was home to a 40 million ton mountain of cowshit earlier in the decade. Coupled with heavy fertilizer use, the end result has been a serious pollution problem.
Re: Malthus revisited (fwd)
Louis Proyect wrote: >> Mark Jones' alleged raising of the overpopulation question leads us once >> again into a discussion of the Marxist critique of Malthus. I would refer >> PEN-L'ers to Michael Perelman's "Marx's Crises Theory: Scarcity, Labor and >> Finance", Lou, I agree with the rest of your post. I should, however, open a small paranthesis that I don't frankly think that comrade Mark has Marx's critique of Malthus in his mind when he defends Bartlett, since Bartlett, is not a Marxist. What we should instead try to address here is the urgent necessity of preserving Marx from the intrusions of social darwinist theories of over-population. so the issue here is *not* to refuse to see _overpopulation as an aspect of capitalism_ but rather to refuse to see it as part of the _solution_ to capitalism's energy crisis actually, it is interesting to see below how Malthus' ideas are linked to a particular religious world view. I have always wondered about how social darwinism and religion meet at some point,although they seem exact opposites in the first place. here is Marx's reply. Marx (Volume 1) pp.766-767: " the principle of population slowly worked out in the 18th century, and then, in the midst of a great social crisis, proclaimed with drums and trumpets as the infallible antitode to the doctrines of Condorcet, etc., was greated jubilantly by the English oligarchy as the great destroyer of all hankerings after a progressive development of humanityLet us note incidentally that although Malthus was a parson of the Church of England he had taken the monastic view of celibacyThe circumstances favourably distinguishes Malthus from other protestant parsons, who have flung off the Catholic requirement of the celibacy of the priesthood, and taken "be fruitfull and multiply" as their special Biblical missionto such an extend that they generally contribute to the increase of population to a really unbecoming extent, while at the same time preaching the principle of population to workers. ... With the exception of the Venetical monk Ortes, an original and clever writer,most of the population theorists are Protestant clerics. For instance Bruckner's Theorie du systeme animal (Leyden 1767) in which the the whole of the modern theory of population is exhaustively terated , using ideas furnished by the passing dispute between Quesnay and his pupil, the elder Mirabeau, then Parson Wallace,Parson Townsend, Parson Malthus and his pupil, the arch Parson Thomas Chalmers, to say nothing of lesser reverend scribblers in this line" Mine, SUNY/Albany
Re: Malthus revisited
Louis Proyect wrote: > > Mark Jones' alleged raising of the overpopulation question leads us once > again into a discussion of the Marxist critique of Malthus. I would refer > PEN-L'ers to Michael Perelman's "Marx's Crises Theory: Scarcity, Labor and > Finance", specifically chapter two on "Marx, Malthus, and the Concept of > Natural Resource Scarcity". It is one of the best things I have ever read > on the subject. A useful resource (no pun) is the collection edited by Ronald Meek *MArx and Engels on the Population Bomb* It includes a fine review essay by Meek himself who argues that Keynes was Malthus in modern garb. Marx and Engels both pointed some of their most fiery polemics at Malthus. Malthus was obviously wrong, birth rates decline when absolute poverty is alleviated and food production increased. As Marx argues in "Malthus as Apologist" in volii of TSV, Malthus' MO was in defending the interests of the landed aristocracy. "not a man of science but a bought advocate, a pleader on behalf of their enemies, a shameless sycophant of the ruling classes"The same thing carries on today, with the landed aristocracy being the most forceful advocates of Malthusianism and the Malthusianism of the mainstream environmental movement (Sierra Club etc.) as well as being the main financial backers of said movement. Sam Pawlett
Malthus revisited
Mark Jones' alleged raising of the overpopulation question leads us once again into a discussion of the Marxist critique of Malthus. I would refer PEN-L'ers to Michael Perelman's "Marx's Crises Theory: Scarcity, Labor and Finance", specifically chapter two on "Marx, Malthus, and the Concept of Natural Resource Scarcity". It is one of the best things I have ever read on the subject. Michael states that Marx avoided a direct confrontation with Malthusianism itself. The reason for this was German socialists, under Lasalle's initiative, had incorporated Malthus's doctrines into their program through their notion of the "Iron Law of Wages." Marx decided that he had enough on his table in explaining the labor theory of value without taking Malthus head-on, besides wanting to avoid factional warfare with the German party. This has caused a serious misinterpretation of Marx's views today, because it would lead to the conclusion that Marx did not think that the question of natural resources and their scarcity had any importance. It would fortify the arguments of "deep ecologists" and "green anarchists" who view Marx and Engels as treating nature as nothing but a huge faucet and drain. Ore, water, crops, etc. come out of the faucet in unlimited supply; labor turns them into commodities; and the waste products go down the drain. This interpretation does not do justice to Marx. Marx treats the question of overpopulation itself as an function of capital's need to deploy labor in the social relations surrounding production. A "relative surplus of population" or "industrial reserve army" comes into existence when traditional means of production are abolished, such as village-based, communal agriculture. As Perelman comments: "The apparent 'overpopulation' that then arises is relative, not to natural conditions or food supply, but to the needs of capital accumulation; that is, capital requires a reserve army of labor power on which it can draw quickly and easily, one that holds the pretensions of the working class in check. Scarcity in this context is scarcity of employment owing to the concentration of the means of production under the control of a small class of capitalists operating according to the logic of profit and competition." (Perelman, p. 31) Besides providing a theoretical approach to the question, Marx also dealt with the historical example of Ireland, which Malthusians cited as a classic example of overpopulation. Marx took another tack entirely. He argued that the massive exodus of people following the potato famine did not improve the standard of living in Ireland. It mirrored a decline that began before 1846, the year of the famine. The depopulation of Ireland was engineered by an English and Irish landlord class that transformed the island from a wheat-producing nation, protected from foreign competition by the corn laws, into a huge pasture for wool-producing sheep. Scarcity of natural resources, like population, could not be understood on its own terms. It arises as a consequence of historically determined social relations. His understanding of scarcity comes into the sharpest focus when discussing agriculture. At first Marx believed that agriculture's problems were the heritage of pre-capitalist formations. The bourgeois revolution would fix everything. In the Communist Manifesto, he includes the "application of chemistry to industry and agriculture" as among the greatest accomplishments of capitalism. In a letter to Engels from this period, Marx states that capitalist agriculture breakthroughs "would put an end to Malthus' theory of the deterioration not only of the 'hands' [i.e., people] but also of the land." The more he studied agriculture under capitalism, the more pessimistic Marx became of these prospects. This change occurred between 1861 and 1863 when he was writing "Theories of Surplus Value," a work which while still promoting the view that capitalist agriculture might even progress at a faster rate than industry, contains a new "greenish" view that is less optimistic: "The moral history...concerning agriculture...is that the capitalist system works against a rational agriculture, or that a rational agriculture is incompatible with the capitalist system (although the latter promotes technical improvements in agriculture), and needs either the hand of the small farmer living by his own labor or the control of associated producers." Marx came to these views not because he became convinced of an early version of the Gaia principle, but because he had been studying agronomy and organic chemistry in some detail. He believed that agricultural chemistry was more important than all of the economists "put together." His agricultural research led him to the conclusion in 1868 that capitalist agriculture "leaves deserts behind it." His section on "Large Scale Industry and Agriculture" in volume one of Capital is virtually a red-green manifesto: "Capitalist production, by
