On Fri, Apr 18, 2014 at 3:15 AM, Ian Glen Walker <walker...@gmail.com>wrote:
> Hi all > > > > More Scientists putting their head above the parapet. A paper positively > reviewing the work of Prof. Arata, by Florentin Smarandache and Vic > Christianto has appeared on vixra under the mathematics section: > > “Unleashing the Quark Within: Lenr, Klein-Gordon Equation, and Elementary > Particle Physics” > > http://vixra.org/abs/1404.0314 > > > > There appears to be a growing consensus in the scientific and engineering > communities that LENR/CF is real. > This is a theory paper. As Norman Ramsey pointed out in his preamble to the DoE's original review of cold fusion: "However, even a *single* short but valid cold fusion period would be revolutionary." If you can't get "scientists" to look at the experimental data, you aren't making progress -- largely because you can't find any scientists. OK, I'll soften that just a touch to be kinder to theorists with this caveat: If, in a theoretic review, there appears proposals for experimental tests that should be reliably replicable and decisive, the review would, indeed, represent progress toward the mainstream.
