----- Original Message ----- From: "habibah silmy" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: <wanita-muslimah@yahoogroups.com>; "Debat Al-Kitab" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Debat Islam Katholik" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Islamkristen" <islamkristen@yahoogroups.com> Cc: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Thursday, December 14, 2006 23:02 Subject: [wanita-muslimah] Fw: Kajian mengupas tentang kebohongan NATAL
----- Forwarded Message ---- From: sally sety <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]; hidayahnet@yahoogroups.com; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; keadilan4all@yahoogroups.com; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; media-dakwah@yahoogroups.com; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; urangawak@yahoogroups.com; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cc: habibah <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Thursday, December 14, 2006 9:52:21 PM Subject: Kajian mengupas tentang kebohongan NATAL ----- Forwarded Message ---- From: sally sety <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]; hidayahnet@yahoogroups.com; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; keadilan4all@yahoogroups.com; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; media-dakwah@yahoogroups.com; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; urangawak@yahoogroups.com; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cc: habibah <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Thursday, December 14, 2006 9:52:21 PM Subject: Kajian mengupas tentang kebohongan NATAL Assalamualaikum wr,wb, Ikuti, FORUM KAJIAN IRENA CENTER Selasa, 19 Desember 2006 Ba'da Isya - selesai. di Masjid Raya AL-HAKIM Menteng "Benarkah Isa lahir 25 Desember ?" Sebuah Kajian yang mengupas tentang kebohongan NATAL Nara Sumber : HJ. IRENA HANDONO diselenggarakan oleh : IRENA CENTER & MASJID RAYA AL-HAKIM info. 021-8853878 021-70732223 MOHON SEBARKAN ****************************************************************** Dari file lama, diambil dari kantong Dora Emon. Maaf footnote itu dalam bahasa Inggris, karena itu merupakan artikel yang diposting ke milis-milis Islam-Kristen, islam-kristen dan debat_islam-kristen. Wassalam, HMNA ***************************************************** BISMILLA-HIRRAHMA-NIRRAHIYM http://www.bismillah.co.nr WAHYU DAN AKAL - IMAN DAN ILMU [Kolom Tetap Harian Fajar] 061. Kelahiran 'Isa bnu Maryam, Isyarat Menurut Injil dan Al Quran Tentulah tulisan ini tidak akan membahas arti kelahiran itu, karena itu bukanlah kompetensi kita untuk membahasnya. Yang akan dibahas hanya perkara bilakah 'Isa ibnu Maryam dilahirkan. Pada tanggal 25 Desember ummat Nashrani di seluruh dunia, kecuali golongan Russian Ortodox Church (Katholik Yunani), merayakan Hari Natal (kelahiran) Yesus Kristus yang ke 1992. Apakah betul 'Isa ibnu Maryam lahir pada tanggal 25 Desember dan tepat 1992 tahun lalu? Di dalam Injil hal itu tidak tercantum. Yang kita ketahui hanya ini, dari Injil Lukas bab 2:1-7: "Pada waktu itu Kaisar Agustus mengeluarkan suatu perintah, menyuruh mendaftarkan semua orang di seluruh dunia. Inilah pendaftaran yang pertama kali diadakan sewaktu Kirenius menjadi wali negeri di Siria. Maka pergilah semua orang mendaftarkan diri, masing-masing di kotanya sendiri. Demikian juga Yusuf pergi dari kota Nazaret di Galilea ke Yudea, ke kota Daud yang bernama Betlehem, karena ia berasal dari keluarga dan keturunan Daud supaya didaftarkan bersama-sama dengan Maria, tunangannya, yang sedang mengandung. Ketika mereka di situ tibalah waktunya bagi Maria untuk bersalin, dan ia melahirkan sorang anak laki-laki, anaknya yang sulung, lalu dibungkusnya dengan lampin dan dibaringkannya di dalam palungan, karena tidak ada tempat bagi mereka di rumah penginapan." Jadi, 'Isa ibnu Maryam menurut Injil dilahirkan sewaktu bangsa Yahudi dijajah oleh imperium Romawi di bawah Kaisar Augustus yang memerintah dari tahun 30 sebelum Masehi sampai tahun 14 sesudah Masehi (untuk selanjutnya akan dituliskan Miladiyah, artinya natal). Sudah pasti 'Isa bnu Maryam lahir sebelum Herodes Agung mati (tahun 4 sebelum Miladiyah), jadi sekitar tahun 8 - 6 sebelum tarikh Kristen yang ditentukan oleh Dionisius Exiguus dalam abad VI. Perhitungan Dionisius mengenai Tarikh Kristen dihitung salah. Meskipun perhitungan Dionisius itu meleset, namun itulah yang diambil sebagai Tarikh Kristen yang resmi diterima di seluruh dunia seperti yang orang pakai sekarang ini. Telanjur dipakai sebelum diteliti secara mendalam sejarah imperium Romawi. Demikian pula mengenai tanggal 25 Desember, itupun tidak disebutkan dalam Injil. Sesungguhnya tanggal 25 Desember itu adalah hari lahirnya dewa Mithras, hari munculnya dewa Matahari. Ini diambil alih dari kebiasaan di Barat dalam merayakan "munculnya matahari" yang selalu mereka rayakan sebelum mereka memeluk agama Nashrani(*). Setelah mereka memeluk agama Nashrani pesta itu dimurnikan maknanya menjadi tanggal untuk memperingati lahirnya "Sang Matahari" yaitu Yesus Kristus yang datang ke dunia ini sebagai "Terang Dunia" seperti dikatakan Injil Yohanes 1:1-18. Dari uraian di atas itu jelas bagi kita bahwa tahun kelahiran 'Isa bnu Maryam adalah tahun 8 - 6 lebih dahulu dari tahun menurut sistem kalender Miladiyah. Yaitu seperti yang diisyaratkan dalam Injil karangan Lukas, pada waktu Kaisar Augustus memerintahkan sensus penduduk untuk kepentingan pemungutan pajak. Demikian pula mengenai tanggal kelahiran 'Isa bnu Maryam bukanlah pada 25 Desember, karena sesungguhnya tanggal 25 Desember itu adalah hari lahirnya dewa Mithras yang diyakini masyarakat barat sebelum beragama Nashrani. (Tentang nama dewa Mithras, atau dewa Matahari yang dipuja oleh bangsa Eropah sekeliling Laut Tengah dan juga dipuja oleh bangsa Parsi dalam nama yang sama, perlu diadakan penelitian apakah ada hubungannya atau hanya kebetulan dengan kemiripan nama dewa Amiterasu, dewa Matahari yang dipuja oleh bangsa Jepang). Bahkan dalam Injil diisyaratkan 'Isa bnu Maryam tidaklah dilahirkan dalam musim dingin. Yaitu tatkala 'Isa bnu Maryam dilahirkan, para gembala sementara menjaga kawanan ternaknya pada malam hari. Seperti diketahui dalam ilmu bumi-alam, tanggal 25 Desember adalah pertengahan musim dingin. Tatkala itu matahari mulai bergeser ke utara setelah selama musim dingin itu bergeser ke selatan pada garis ekliptika di bola langit. Mana ada gembala yang berani menggembalakan ternaknya di malam hari, di udara luar yang terbuka, dalam pertengahan musim dingin. Boleh dilihat di peta bahwa Galilea sampai Judea terletak di sebelah utara garis Tropic of Cancer, yaitu daerah yang mempunyai 4 musim: dingin, semi, panas, gugur. Bahwa kelahiran 'Isa bnu Maryam bukan dalam musim dingin, ada diisyaratkan dalam Al Quran. Adapun Al Quran dalam S. Maryam mengisyaratkan bahwa 'Isa bnu Maryam dilahirkan ketika musimnya buah kurma sedang ranum di pohonnya. Menurut Al Quran Malaikat Jibril dua kali mendatangi Maryam. Kedatangannya yang pertama dalam wujud manusia, ketika Jibril menginformasikan kepada Maryam akan melahirkan seorang anak laki-laki yang suci, (S. Maryam 19). Dengan kekuasaan Allah anak itu dikandung Maryam, tanpa prolog proses biologik, jadi tanpa ayah. Itulah sebabnya dalam Al Quran disebut 'Isa bnu Maryam, Isa Putera Maryam. Penekanan dalam S.Maryam 19 itu dengan ghulaman zakiyyan, anak laki-laki yang suci, untuk menangkis tuduhan menghujat masyarakat Yahudi tentang hal kelahiran 'Isa bnu Maryam tanpa ayah. Adapun kedatangan Jibril untuk kedua kalinya kepada Maryam, bukan dalam wujud manusia, melainkan hanya suaranya saja yang kedengaran oleh Maryam, pada waktu Maryam baru saja melahirkan. Fahamaltahu fantadzabat bihi makanan qashiyyan, (S.Maryam 22). Maka ia (Maryam) mengandungnya (Isa), lalu ia pergi dengan kandungannya itu ke tempat yang jauh. Wa huzzi ilayki bijiz'i nnakhlati tusaqith 'alayki ruthaban janiyyan, (S.Maryam 25). (Maka kata Jibril): Dan goncanglah batang kurma itu, nanti (dari pohon itu) berguguran atasmu kurma yang ranum. Jadi kesimpulannya, 'Isa bnu Maryam dilahirkan pada waktu sensus penduduk di imperium Romawi seperti yang diisyaratkan oleh Injil, yaitu 8 - 6 tahun lebih dahulu dari sistem penanggalan Miladiyah. Artinya pada tahun pertama penanggalan Miladiyah 'Isa bnu Maryam telah berumur 6 - 8 tahun. Dan bahwa 'Isa bnu Maryam tidak dilahirkan dalam musim dingin, pada 25 Desember, melainkan pada waktu gembala mampu menggembalakan ternaknya di malam hari, seperti juga yang diisyaratkan oleh Injil. Yaitu pada waktu pohon kurma sedang ranum buahnya, seperti yang diisyaratkan oleh Al Quran. Walhasil informasi dari Injil dengan informasi dari Al Quran saling mengisi, dalam hal bilakah 'Isa bnu Maryam dilahirkan, baik bulan maupun tahunnya. WaLlahu a'lamu bishshawab. *** Makassar, 27 Desember 1992 [H.Muh.Nur Abdurrahman] =============================== (*) BUSMILLA-HIRRAHMA-NIRRAHIYM PAGANISM, THE CULT OF SUN-WORSHIP and the Origin of Christian Theology by H.Muh.Nur Abdurrahman Sun+day is the day to worship the Sun-God. Worship of the sun formed a most popular type of religion for the backward races of mankind. This grand and majestic luminary (the ancient Egyptians called it Ra) appears to a nascent, half-cultured mind as a source of life and the Lord of Light, and the various phases through which it has to pass provide him occasions for giving expression to his inborn instincs of fear and hope and for celebrating festivals accordingly. The sun begins to decline (in northern hemisphere) after the automnal equinox, and its decline reaches the last stage at the approach of the winter solstice, after which it again begins to increase in its light and warmth and ascends the horizon as if re-born in the underworld. This progress continues till the vernal equinox approaches, when days become of equal length with nights, and progress seems to be impeded. But the "crisis" is soon overcome; days becomes longer than night, meaning a final victory of the lord of light over the prince of darkness. Thus among all Sun-worshipping communities, the autumnal equinox became an occation of fear and grief, because of the belief that their deity had fallen into clutches of the demon of darkness. On the other hand, the winter solstice and vernal equinox (the corresponding festivals in christendom are Christmas and Easter) became the day of the "birth" of the Sun-God and the second day of his "triumph" over the Prince of Darkness. As a matter of fact, frankly speaking, every one can learn from the paganism about the origin of christian theology, the theology of Jesus Christ as the only begotten son, the saviour, the sin bearer, the redeemer who suffered death, through passion play which ended with crucifixion, for redemption of mankind. Legend of the Mediterranian Sun-God Sun-worship was, at the time of the appearance of Jesus, the universally-prevelent religion of the Roman Empire, though the names given to the Sun-God in different countries were different. The well known Sun-Gods, whose worship had been popular in the Mediterranian countries at one time or the other, are: Attis of Phygia, Adonis of Syria, Dionysius or Bacchus of Greece, Bel of Babylon, Horus of Egypt, Mithras or Mithra of Persia. Brief sketches of the legends of these Sun-Gods will reveal the sources of the Christian legend. Attis He was regarded as "the only begotten Son "and Saviour". He was bled to death on March 24th at the foot of a pine-tree and his votaries believed that his blood had renewed the fertility of the earth, and thus brought a new life to humanity. He, however, rose from the dead, and his resurrection along with his death was celebrated by his votaries. Every year on the 24th day of march, they would first fasten his image to a pine-tree and then lay it in a tomb with wailing and mourning. On the next day they would find the tomb empty and celebrate the resurrection with the great rejoicing. Sacramental meal and baptism of blood was special feature of the festival of his cult. Adonis or Tammuz He was the "Saviour" of Syria. He suffered death for redemption of mankind, but rose again in the spring. His resurrection was commemorated by agreat annual festival. The old testament refers to the weeping and wailing of women over Tammuz (Ezekiel,viii,14). His votaries called him the "crucified" Tao (divine love personified, vide: Mythology of the Aryan Nations, vol.ii.p.113). Tammuz belonged to that class of idols which originally design to represent the Promised Saviour. Dionysius or Bacchus He was the "only begotten Son" of Jupiter (Zupitri = god the father) and was born on December 25th. He was a redeemer, liberator and saviour. "It is I," so says bacchus to mankind, "who guide you; it is I who protect you, and who save you; I am alpha and omega", vide: anacalypsis, vol.i.p.302. Wine had an important place in the festival of his cult. He was slain for redeeming humanity and was called "the Slain One", "the Sin Bearer", the Redeemer. His passion play was celebrated every year representing his death and resurrection. Bel or Ba'al He was the Sun-God of Babylon and the history of his life is extremely astonishing in so far as his passion play has a very close resemblance with the Christian passion story even in details. Modern arhaelogical researches have brought to light some very bewildering facts which go to prove that Babilonian mithology played an important role in the early stages of Christianity. In 1903-4, the german exavators at kala shergat, the site of ancient assur, discovered two cuneiform documents. When deciphered, they were found to contain the narrative of passion play of ba'al. An english journal, the Quest, London, January 1922 published its translation. These are some of them: 1. Ba'al is taken prisoner 1. Jesus is taken prisoner 2. Ba'al is tried in the house on the hall of justice 2. Jesus is tried of the high priest and the hall of pilate 3. Ba'al is smitten 3. Jesus is scourged 4. Ba'al is led away to the mount 4. Jesus is led away to Golgotha ------ 11 a goddes sits with ba'al; she comes to tend him 11 Mary Magdalene and the other Mary sit before the tomb ------ 13 Ba'al again brought back to life; he comes again out of the mount 13 Jesus' restoration to life, his rising from the grave 14 his chief feast in March at the spring equinox, is celebrated also as his triumph over the powers of darkness 14 his festival approximately at the spring equinox ia also celebrated as his triumph over the powers of darkness Horus Horus of Egypt was born on december 29th. He was slain, but came again to life after two or three days and three nights. Belief in the God-Man in the form of horus became the chief element in Egyptian religion, and remained for thousands of years the faith of the people through the tangled skein of religious life in Egypt until Horus passed into the form of the God-Man Jesus Christ. Mithras or Mithra He was the Sun-God of the Persians, the perfect prototype of Jesus Christ in which Christmas and Easter were two most inportant festivals. This Divine Saviour's first worshippers were shepherd; and the day of his nativity was December 25th, His followers had seven sacraments of which the most important were baptism, confirmation and eucharist supper, at which the communicants partook of the Divine Mithra under the species of bread and wine. The story, however, does not end here. Modern scholars have unearthed a vast mass of evidence which proves beyond doubt that not only the life of Chiristian Jesus but the whole superstructure of Christianity as such has been built up on pagan foundation. As a matter of fact, Christianity, as it has existed since the transformation wrought by the Neo-Platonist Paul, is simply a continuation of pre-Christian paganism. WaLlahu a'lamu bisshawab ******************************************* __________________________________________________ Apakah Anda Yahoo!? Lelah menerima spam? Surat Yahoo! memiliki perlindungan terbaik terhadap spam http://id.mail.yahoo.com