I know this thread is getting long in the tooth but aren't we missing something here?


If you're on a major label the relevant bodies (BMI/ASCAP and then RIAA/BPI, I don't really care about the details) will fight your corner with a huge gang of lawyers and X million dollar fines.

The take home message is: Don't f**k with major label music go and pirate some independents because we won't (or are less inclined) to chase that up.

We will then be left with a two tier system where independents won't be able to go the digital distribution route even if they wanted to for fear of all their stuff just disappearing into P2P and them making no money. (Remember the pro-p2p argument only really works if people want the tunes they find on p2p on vinyl, see Tom's post below....I'm not discussing p2p tho. The point is we're in an era now where digital djing is possible and vinyl isn't a necessity). The majors on the other hand will obviously protect their IP vigorously and people will be more inclined get legit DLs of that, ie. more money, and access to the new digital market, for the majors.

Or have I missed something here?

robin...


point being that you gave money into the system to keep it going.
especially in independent music this is very important. if you
want to say "dont buy from big labels, steal from them" im not
going to argue. however i cant see what gain can be had from
stealing from indie labels at all. i love the idea of music being
free. i DL mp3s but i always buy what i love when its available.

Reply via email to