Reviewer: Al Morton
Review result: Has Nits
This is the OPS-DIR review of -12
1) "This specification introduces a new token called a cryptographic
identifier (Crypto-ID) that is used to prove indirectly the ownership
of an address that is being registered by means of [RFC8505]."
during Neighbor Discovery in
"...a 6LoWPAN Low Power Lossy
Network (LLN), typically a stub network connected to a larger IP
network via a Border Router called a 6LBR per [RFC6775]."
2) This seems like a worthwhile update to RFC8505.
The section describing the Update aspect is helpful, but ...
Nit: there should also a sentence in the Abstract indicating the Update
status.
The scope of operation is very limited, hence no operational issues
detected.
3) The SEC-DIR review will likely be more interesting: this reviewer's
experience
doesn't foster review of LLN in any depth.
4) The Doc Shepherd's form indicates that the last 4 versions benefited from
review by
knowledgeable persons in the Security Area.
_______________________________________________
6lo mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/6lo
