Alex,

there are lots of IP-over-foo documents that have much more logic than 6LoWPAN.

-- the PPP series of documents, which by reference includes functions like ROHC (which has its own segmentation layer);
-- IP over ATM?
-- and how about MPLS (which also includes ROHC via RFC 4901);
-- and an example for something quite similar to 6LoWPAN (including fragmentation), RFC 3146 (IPv6 over Firewire)/RFC 2734 (IP over Firewire).

This is why I don't understand the goal of specifying 6LoWPAN fragmentation at a layer situated below the IPv6 layer.

It is a bit late to make that argument:
RFC 4919 (defining that goal) and RFC 4944 (specifying the protocol) were approved in 2007.

Gruesse, Carsten

_______________________________________________
6lowpan mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/6lowpan

Reply via email to