>> I think we're scaring the newcomers.
> That worries me too. We could take this discussion somewhere
> else if necessary - it's not really about abc per se. Any
> newcomers like to comment? Or alternatively somebody post
> some tunes so this isn't the only thread in town :-)
Lemme try to do both. How well would the matching algorithms suggested so
far do on identifying the variation-ness of variations? Like this set?
X:70
T:To Daunton Me
C:James Oswald
S:Caledonian Pocket Companion
Q:Slow % which will probably make most ABC implementations throw a fit,
% but it's what Oswald wrote and it damn well needs to be allowed
% for in the standard.
M:4/4
L:1/8
K:Edor
F>A | B2 (E>F) E2 (A>G) | (F>A)(E>F) D2
(d>e) |\
(fe)(dB) (d<B)(A<F) | B2 (E>F) E2
:|
(TF>E)| D2 (d>e) d3 e | (fe/f/) (e/d/)(c/B/) A3
d |\
B2 (e>f) e3 f |({a}g)f ({f}e)d B2
(d>e) |
f2 ({a}g)f e2 ({g}f)e | d>edB ABde
|\
(f>d)(e>B) (d>A) (B/A/F/A/)| B2 E>F E2
:|
(F>A)| B2 E2 d3 c/B/ | A(B/G/) ({A}G)(F/E/) D2
d>e |\
fdef (DEF)A | B2 E>F E2
:|
(TF>E)| D2 (FA) d3 e | f(3(e/d/c/) dB A3
(d/c/)|\
BEGB (e^de)f | (g/a/f/g/ e/f/)(d/e/) B2
(d>e) |
(fe/f/ g)f (ed/e/ f)e | d(c/B/) dF A2
(d>e) |\
f/(e/d/f/) e/(d/B/e/) (d/B/A/d/) (B/A/F/A/)| B2 E>F E2
:|
F>A | B E2 F G(A/B/) AG | F/(d/c/B/) A/(G/F/E/) D2
(d>e) |\
f (3(e/d/c/) d (3(c/B/A/) BDEF | B2 E>F E2
:|
(TF>E)| D F2 A2 d2 f | a(g/f/) e/d/c/B/ A3
(G/F/)|\
E G2 B2 e Bf | (g/a/f/)g/ (e/f/d/)e/ B2
(d>e) |
f a2 (g/f/) (e/f/) g2 (f/e/)| de/f/ (e/d/)(c/B/) ABde
|\
(f/e/)d (e/d/)B (d/B/)A (B/A/F/A/)| B2 E>F E2
:|
M:6/8
"Jig"
F |B2E E2F|(AF)E D2(d/e/)|(fe)d (DE)F|(BA)F E2:|\
F |D2d d2e|(fe)d (BA)F |
E2e E2g |(fe)d B2
(d/e/)|f3 Te3 | d2B (AB)d |(FE)D (EF)A|(BA)F E2:|
Note that this was edited using Barfly, and the formatting as staff
notation depends on BarFly's line-end design bug; you may need to add
extra continuation marks where lines of text don't end with a barline.
To subscribe/unsubscribe, point your browser to: http://www.tullochgorm.com/lists.html
