Forgeot Eric wrote:
>
> From: Toby Rider <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
> Subject: [abcusers] BOUNCE [EMAIL PROTECTED]:
> Non-member submission from [ForgeotEric <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>]
Apparently your message was mistakenly caught by the new non-members
filter, and then Toby corrected it by resubmitting manually.
A bit weird in this case, but as long as such mistakes are caught and
corrected, there shouldn't be any reason to worry.
Now, for the original posting:
>
> How will the standard evolve as far as ties and slurs are
> concerned ?
...
>
> I understand that ties and slurs aren't the same, but slurs and
> triplets can interact badly, like in this example (I transcribed
> the notes as they were written )
Although they might be historically related, ties and slurs are two
separate issues. And neither of them has anything whatsoever to do with
the square or curved bracket often placed over notes in a tuplet. The
fact that these three items look so similar in standard notation, should
be considered a bug in the standard - unforunately one it's a bit too
late to do anything about now.
The fact that some abc programs confuse the three, should be considered
as bugs in the respective programs and be treated accordingly.
End of discussion ;-)
Nice tune, btw, Eric :-)
Where did you get it from?
I mean, although Thorvald Trondsg�rd comes from Folldal, slightly
outside the central parts of Hedmark and Oppland (the part of Norway
that just doesn't exist as far as collectors and publishers of
traditional music are concerned), it's still not one of the "officially
approved folk music regions" of Norway, so you wouldn't expect to find
the music in any standard collection.
Cheers
Frank Nordberg
http://www.musicaviva.com
To subscribe/unsubscribe, point your browser to: http://www.tullochgorm.com/lists.html
