| >Of course if a key signature had a note flatted and the music had it
| >double-sharped then (1) a triple-sharp would be needed and (2) the input
| >file is silly anyway so who cares?
|
| No (1) is wrong because accidentals are absolute, rather than relative.

Beg to differ.  If it was flatted in the key-sig and is double-sharped then
it is to play 3 semitones higher than normal.  If that was transposed into
the open key then it would require a triple-sharp or else moving it onto a
different staff position (breaking your staff placement rule which turns out
to be the same as my "slavishly copy" rule).

L.


To subscribe/unsubscribe, point your browser to: http://www.tullochgorm.com/lists.html

Reply via email to