| So where are we to find the results of your searchbot search?

Is that a great straight line or what?  Anyway some  people
have found this useful:

http://trillian.mit.edu/~jc/music/abc/findtune.html

If you want to see the actual search results,  rather  than
just  look for a tune, there's a link to the index files on
the page.  These are from the previous search, a few  weeks
ago.  I usually don't update the index files until a search
run has finished, unless someone makes a special request to
get  their tunes into the indexes.  So the current search's
results won't be available for a couple days.

This has been an interesting project to work on. Of course,
it's just one of a whole flock of specialized searches that
people are developing.  By now, we have lots of  experience
with  the  keyword-oriented  search sites.  We all know how
useful they are.  But their tendency to turn  up  unrelated
things that use similar words has become one more source of
humor in society at large.  So people are  trying  to  find
ways  to  do  a  better  job.   One approach is specialized
searches by software  that  has  some  understanding  of  a
specific subject.  That's what my site is all about.

One thing that was unfortunate was that "abc" was chosen as
the name of this notation.  Type that into any search site,
and you'll see why it wasn't a very good name.  "abc music"
isn't much better, due to one large corporation. And you'll
also see a lot of results on "the ABC's of ...."

Actually, I have had some success with using google. I have
a  little  perl  script  that  asks google about "abc tunes
notation", extracts the URLs, and tries  them  as  starting
points. Among the 600 or so distinct URLs in the first 1000
results, there were about 60 that actually had abc tunes. A
10%  success rate is pretty decent for a keyword match on a
common term like "abc".  So I'm not criticising google; I'm
just one of the gang who sees their good and bad points.

This 10% rate can be greatly improved by  using  a  program
that  knows  how  to  follow hyperlinks and can extract abc
tunes from the files.

The original motive for all this, of course, was so that  I
could find tunes when I wanted them.  It was obvious 5 or 6
years ago that people were putting their tunes online.  But
asking in a mailing list is a slow way to find something. I
got to thinking "Hey, you're a programmer; you shouldn't be
doing  that by hand.  It's a computer's job." Then I told a
few people about it.  I've gotten quite a lot  of  feedback
since then.

And, of course, at every opportunity, I tell people that my
tune search site is only as useful as the body of abc music
that's on the web.  There's a lot of good stuff out  there,
but  there's  much more that's missing.  So when people ask
about something that can't be found, I usually suggest that
they  should  do  the transcription and put it online.  And
send me the URL.

(Maybe I should add a URL entry form to my search pages.)


To subscribe/unsubscribe, point your browser to: http://www.tullochgorm.com/lists.html

Reply via email to