Dear friends

a very interesting article by chidanand rajghata in crest edition of times
of india!

read it below.


There is a piquant story about the late Indian Communist leader EMS
Namboodiripad, one of many famous people (Tiger Woods, Marilyn Monroe, Elvis
Presley among them) who was prone to stuttering. A reporter once asked EMS
if he always stammered (stutter and stammer are the same). "No, only when I
speak, " EMS is said to have joked, presumably inducing a momentary stammer
in the witless reporter.

India remains a cruel society to people with disabilities. As it is, we are
one of the most discriminatory societies on earth, victimising people on a
range of biases from religion and caste to color and wealth etc, but the
plight of a person with a disability is rough in a hungry society. An
aggressive, combative, predatory population on the make has no eyes or ears
for the slightest incapacity. Oh sure, there is the occasional pang of
individual pity and concern, but as a collective, we have little mindspace
for them. It shows in our films, on our roads, in our buildings, and in our
books.

Which is why a film like Aamir Khan's Taare Zameen Par, which addresses a
minor disability like dyslexia, was a very small step in redressing the
unsparing cruelty Indian society and film industry has inflicted on the
impaired and disabled. From caricaturing cripples and hunchbacks to
parodying the stuttering and the deaf, there isn't one disability
Bollywood's brain-dead scriptwriters haven't made fun of. Maybe TZP will
induce a new sensitivity, but don't count on it. It is after all a
reflection of the society we live in.

Another common disability is getting plenty of attention these days thanks
to the movie The King's Speech, which centers around an English monarch's
struggle to overcome a stammer. Colin Firth's performance as King George VI
has made him top contender for an Oscar for best actor, but even if he
doesn't nail it, the movie has touched on a fairly common impairment. Even
in a country that has made giant leaps in addressing disabilities, the film
has been embraced by the Stuttering Foundation of America as "rare
opportunity to teach the widest possible audience about the complexities of
stuttering, and the availability of treatment and support. "

As with most disabilities, stuttering is also much misunderstood and
maligned. Some 68 million people worldwide - one per cent of the world
population - is prone to stuttering. Demosthenes, the father of rhetoric,
and Moses, the patriarch prophet, are among the earliest known stutterers.
Down the ages, brilliant minds (Darwin, Newton, Churchill, etc) and
beautiful people (Julia Roberts, Nicole Kidman Hugh Grant etc) overcame what
is at best a minor growing-up wrinkle that can be easily fixed, rather than
treated as a handicap.

In fact, the term handicapped itself is in disfavour these days. It comes
from Elizabethian Age, when people with disabilities were ejected from
hospitals and shelters for the poor and forced to beg and given a cap in
which to collect alms (hence handicap ). Today, the US is among the few
countries that is a leader in easing the life of the disabled, an American
example worth emulating instead of the many tawdry practices we follow
blindly.

It wasn't any different from India even up until 50 years ago. Like with
much of the western world, treatment of disabled ranged from seeing them as
sinners possessed by evil (from ancient times to the 1800) to regarding them
as genetically defective or inferior (1800s to 1970s). As late as 1824, the
Commonwealth of Virginia passed a state law that allowed for sterilization
(without consent) of individuals found to be "feeble-minded, insane,
depressed, mentally handicapped, epileptic and other. "

The decision removed all restraints for eugenicists, and probably muted
American criticism of Nazi excesses, although by this time Roosevelt had
become the first person with a serious physical disability to be elected U.
S President. Although Roosevelt signed the Social Security Act, establishing
federal old-age benefits and grants to the states for assistance to blind
individuals and disabled children, he himself continued his "splendid
deception" of concealing his disability from the American public.

It was only in the 1960s that Washington moved to seriously address the
disability issue. The American National Standard Institute (ANSI) published
American Standard Specifications for Making Buildings Accessible to, and
Usable by, the Physically Handicapped. The landmark document became the
basis for subsequent codes. The Urban Mass Transportation Act of 1964
required public transport vehicles to be accessible to elderly and
handicapped persons.

By the 1990s, there was such broad acceptance of the disabled as a part of
the national fabric that Bob Dole's paralyzed hand was never an issue in his
presidential bid in 1996. A society that celebrated the English physicist
Stephen Hawking (motor neuron disease) didn't hesitate to elect Max Cleland
(lost both legs and an arm in Vietnam) to the Senate. Stammering, in
comparison, is a mere hiccup - a disability that has not stopped
Vice-president Joe Biden, who overcame it as a child, from becoming
America's bloviator-in-chief.

Of course, not everyone who overcomes a disability is going to become a
Hawking, much less a Milton (blind) or Beethoven (deaf). But 21st century
knowledge and sensitivity can at least provide a level playing field. India,
with more than 60 million disabled, must not stutter in its response.
Get numbers right this time, help the census with correct disability info!
Question 9 relates to disability.

Reply via email to