Hi,

We have a simple AD. Just one domain and nothing extra (no childs etc). 

BUT what we do have is a domain spread across different IP addressing
systems and DC's behind Firewalls that have to do NAT.

One of our sites uses private IP numbers (site A) and another uses
public (site B)..

What this in effect means is that A DC will get one address from the
site it is in say 10.1.5.1 and everything on that site will see it as
that (including itself) and from site B it is say 115.151.9.10 so the
DC's on that site see it as that.

The first and main DC is in site A 

We have always in the past managed to get round the island issues by
have a primary DNS and Secondarys on each site and pointing servers to
these making the sure the DC DO NOT point to themselves.  BUT it's a
little hit and miss.

We now have a further site which is a subsite of site B and uses private
addresses (so thats private within and site of public attaching to a
site of private).  The New DC in the New site is currently on its own
(and is its own DNS) and was okay .. for about a week and now is an
island.  I can't point it at any other DNS as It's number will be wrong
(due to NAT) in the other sites ones (and they have dynamic updates on).

Will adding a second DnS into the site and using that instead fix it ?
or does anyone have some sage advice (apart from don't do what you are
doing ... it's not an option). I can't point all my DC's at one DNS and
can't use AD dns because of the different IP numbers for the servers
depending on where you look at them from.

Help.

Mike Maple


-----------------------------------------------------
THE INFORMATION IN THIS E-MAIL AND IN ANY ATTACHMENTS IS CONFIDENTIAL

AND MAY BE PRIVILEGED OR OTHERWISE PROTECTED FROM DISCLOSURE. 
IF YOU ARE NOT THE INTENDED RECIPIENT AND HAVE RECEIVED IT IN ERROR YOU ARE ON NOTICE 
OF ITS STATUS. 
PLEASE NOTIFY THE SENDER IMMEDIATELY BY RETURN EMAIL AND THEN DELETE THIS EMAIL AND 
ANY ATTACHMENT FROM YOUR SYSTEM. 
YOU MUST NOT RETAIN, COPY OR USE THIS E-MAIL OR ANY ATTACHMENT FOR ANY PURPOSE, NOR 
DISCLOSE ALL OR ANY PART OF ITS CONTENTS TO ANY OTHER PERSON: 

TO DO SO COULD BE A BREACH OF CONFIDENCE

EMAIL MAY BE SUSCEPTIBLE TO DATA CORRUPTION, INTERCEPTION AND UNAUTHORISED AMENDMENT, 
AND WE DO NOT ACCEPT LIABILITY FOR ANY SUCH CORRUPTION, INTERCEPTION OR AMENDMENT OR 
THE CONSEQUENCES THEREOF. 

WE MAY MONITOR THE CONTENT OF EMAILS SENT AND RECEIVED VIA OUR NETWORK FOR VIRUSES OR 
UNAUTHORISED USE AND FOR OTHER LAWFUL BUSINESS PURPOSES. 
WE DO NOT ACCEPT RESPONSIBILITY FOR ANY LOSS OR DAMAGE ARISING FROM A VIRUS IN ANY 
EMAIL OR ATTACHMENT.

-----------------------------------------------
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

List info   : http://www.activedir.org/mail_list.htm
List FAQ    : http://www.activedir.org/list_faq.htm
List archive: http://www.mail-archive.com/activedir%40mail.activedir.org/

Reply via email to