I have got some results from testing with the .NET framework 1.1 beta, both
in a native 1.1 environment and a mixed 1.0 and 1.1 environment. Note these
are all results from comparing TCP and HTTP remoting channels, not web
service, which also use HTTP transport, but are hosted in IIS.


Running locally on a .NET framework 1.1 beta

>TestChannels -client

Connecting to localhost
Testing TCP Channel
Done with RegularMethod batch! 3.688
Done with RegularMethodReturn batch! 3.844
Done with OneWay batch! 2.969
DONE Testing TCP Channel

Testing HTTP Channel
Done with RegularMethod batch! 13.219
Done with RegularMethodReturn batch! 13.593
Done with OneWay batch! 16.485
DONE Testing HTTP Channel

Interestingly here the TCP channel and the HTTP channel are slightly faster
than under 1.0. The [OneWay] TCP channel has made great improvements and is
now faster than the regular method (as it should be). But the HTTP channel's
[OneWay] method is going backwards, now it is not only slower under 1.1 than
it was under 1.0, but it is now slower than the regular methods.



Running with a client on a .NET framework 1.1 beta and the server running on
a .NET framework 1.0 sp2.

>TestChannels -client=hebe

Connecting to hebe
Testing TCP Channel
Done with RegularMethod batch! 3.093
Done with RegularMethodReturn batch! 3.266
Done with OneWay batch! 11.421
DONE Testing TCP Channel

Testing HTTP Channel
Done with RegularMethod batch! 10.578
Done with RegularMethodReturn batch! 10.906
Done with OneWay batch! 4.422
DONE Testing HTTP Channel

Again the across machine version of the tests runs faster than the local
across process tests, however the results are more pronounced. The HTTP
channel is nearly 3 seconds faster than locally on the same machine.

The TCP [OneWay] call is still slow 2.9 seconds locally => 11.4 seconds
across the network, but at least it is not the 86.3 seconds it used to take!
The HTTP [OneWay] methods are running twice as fast in this combination as
previously in a 1.0 to 1.0 networked config.


Running with the client on .NET framework 1.0 sp2 and the server running on
.NET framework 1.1 beta.

>TestChannels.exe -client=cupid

Connecting to cupid
Testing TCP Channel
Done with RegularMethod batch! 3.766
Done with RegularMethodReturn batch! 3.984
Done with OneWay batch! 8.203
DONE Testing TCP Channel

Testing HTTP Channel
Done with RegularMethod batch! 11.829
Done with RegularMethodReturn batch! 12.421
Done with OneWay batch! 9.688
DONE Testing HTTP Channel

With the client running on the old 1.0 framework we loose some of our speed
shown above. However the [OneWay] methods are again showing interesting
results. The TCP channel methods are faster! But the HTTP methods are
slower!

It looks like the 1.1 framework will make some positive speedups to the
remoting layer, but what is going on with those OneWay methods?

You can read messages from the Advanced DOTNET archive, unsubscribe from Advanced 
DOTNET, or
subscribe to other DevelopMentor lists at http://discuss.develop.com.

Reply via email to