Does" high aesthetic quality" mean true Identity?
mando
On Nov 11, 2008, at 8:02 AM, Chris Miller wrote:
If every artifact that's been divorced from the context of its
excavation is
to called a "knickknack" -- then most of the ancient objects found
in art
museums today would qualify as such.
While I consider Knickknacks to be the kind of things my wife buys
for a
dollar at Walgreen's to give as party favors.
Are the great seated Bodhisattvas in the central hallway of the
A.I.C. to be
called "knickknacks" ? For shame! Those are the best things in
the entire
museum! (and the label indicates -- that we have no idea where they
came
from)
*****
But I agree with the archeologists that looting should be made as
unprofitable
as possible -- by refusing to let any more of that stuff enter art
museums.
That keeps it from being validated (just as new art gets validated)
-- and
makes the purchase of it for a high price more risky.
The community of Biblical scholars has taken that one step further
-- and they
forbid looted artifacts to be mentioned in any literature
recognized by their
profession.
I suppose that will frustrate some scholars -- just as keeping some
pieces out
of art museums will frustrate some art lovers.
But speaking as an art lover -- especially of selected ancient
artifacts -- I
don't really care -- because there already is way too much stuff
for me to see
in my lifetime -- and there already are tons of good stuff in museum
basements. Instead of collecting second and third rate authentic
artifacts --
art museums should be be showing perfect casts of first-rate aesthetic
material.
My dispute with both archaeologists and museum directors -- is
that neither
seems to have much interest in high aesthetic quality - and how
that is what
makes the artifacts they handle really valuable.
_____________________________________________________________
Click to compare psych/counseling degrees in a free directory of
programs.
http://thirdpartyoffers.netzero.net/TGL2211/fc/
Ioyw6ijnep4Q27yHb8gGpqtaYDw70A
OwVth6a6ItYD3GeLDoVMwlwQ/?count=1234567890
