While I wish them luck, I'm very skeptical.  Their analysis of hippocampal 
functionality is somewhat superficial, using only an analysis of large extracellular 
potentials.  

An analogy would be trying to recreate the functionality of a PCI bus by averaging 
together the electrical activity on all of the individual wires and only worrying 
about recreating that signal.   You're averaging over the real information content, 
except in this case, the PCI bus has a 100k wires instead of the 50(?) you'll find in 
a modern computer

Furthermore, sticking stimulating electrodes into a dying hippocampal slice and 
blasting away with enormous currents isn't a terribly accurate analog of real 
hippocampal function.  

Also, treat the verification experiments with a very generous portion of healthy 
skepticism.  They will likely submit the subjects to an enormous battery of tests and 
pick out the very few that show a difference without proper application of Bonferonni 
adjustment.  Fear the scientist with a point to prove, there is no limit to the 
statistical shenanigans that can be used to pull something out of nothing.  

-Brad 

-------
To unsubscribe, change your address, or temporarily deactivate your subscription, 
please go to http://v2.listbox.com/member/[EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to