John Scanlon wrote:
James Ratcliff wrote:
"In some form or another we are going to HAVE to have a natural language
interface, either a translation program that can convert our english to
the machine understandable form, or a simplified form of english that
is trivial for a person to quickly understand and write."
This is what my language Jinnteera does. It could be called
"simplified English" but it really is its own language. It is similar
to SQL in that it is both a knowledge-base management language,
with scripting capabilities, plus, most importantly, it has the
expressibilty of English with a formal unambiguous parsability. And it
is easy to learn and use. This does not solve the central AI problem,
but it provides, along with the knowledge-base architecture it
is designed for (similar to a database management sytem), a general AI
shell, within which, any AI algorithms can be experimented with.
I hate to give this out freely, but I can't help expressing my ideas.
Maybe with cooperation we can solve this problem.
When you say that it "provides ... a general AI shell, within which any
AI algorithms can be experimented with ...", I find myself exasperated
[tho' not to worry, I am exasperated a lot ;-) ] -- it does not provide
a language shell within which *any* of the algorithms that I work with
can be experimented with. There is not even a shred of relationship
between the kind of 'simplified-natural-language' systems and interfaces
being discussed on this list right now, and the entire class of
intelligent systems that I would consider the most viable candidates for
cognition.
So, within the confines of certain conventional stuff talked about in
whatever they teach in CS Artificial Intelligence courses these days,
maybe these interfaces would help ... but it would be overstating the
case to say that this includes all AI designs.
Just wanted to make that disclaimer, that's all.
Richard Loosemore.
-----
This list is sponsored by AGIRI: http://www.agiri.org/email
To unsubscribe or change your options, please go to:
http://v2.listbox.com/member/?list_id=303