On Sun, Sep 28, 2008 at 15:08, Ed Murphy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Detail: http://zenith.homelinux.net/cotc/viewcase.php?cfj=2186 > > ============================== CFJ 2186 ============================== > > Phill sent the message quoted (as evidence #1 - eir > registration) > > ======================================================================== > > Caller: tusho > > Judge: woggle > Judgement: > > ======================================================================== > > History: > > Called by tusho: 24 Sep 2008 10:56:38 GMT > Assigned to woggle: (as of this message) > > ========================================================================
The obvious issue here is whether the message's claim that the published was Phill has been ratified. If it has been ratified, the CFJ is true. It appears no challenge was issued within the self-ratification time limit, and no challenge was issued within one month before this message's publication. Therefore, the claim has self-ratified, and I judge TRUE. (Note that this does not answer the question of who Phill is for other in-game purposes: here the only things ratified would be the "claim as to who published [the public message]". Perhaps this means that Phill was ratified to be the publisher, but knowing now that Phill was a another name under which tusho operated we'll have to adjust our tracked game state. (Certianly, now, Phill is a valid synonym for tusho.) Perhaps the claim (for R2170 purposes) includes that the publisher was a first-class person who had not previously registered (which doesn't necessarily grant Phill first-class personhood at any other time).) -woggle
