On Thu, 29 Jul 2010, Sean Hunt wrote:
> I intend, with 2 support, to appeal this judgment, as it implies that the win
> announcement is in fact the adoption of the proposal, but does not fully
> address whether a posting the text of a proposal purporting to award a win is
> the same as announcing that one or more players win the game, which is
> required to satisfy Rule 2186.
Gratuitous: It DOES address this. It says that posting the proposal text alone
ISN'T enough. But posting the two facts "Proposal 6470 has been adopted"
followed,
in the same announcement, by "here is the text of Proposal 6470: [this set of
persons] has won" IS enough, because together contains all the information
for 2186 and 2188 in one announcement. See the list of possibilities I just
sent
to discussion.
-G.
