> ============== Criminal Case 2959 (Interest Index = 0) ===============
> BobTHJ violated R2143 (Power-1) by failing to complete the
> Anarchist's weekly duties in the week of August 10-16.
I don't remember the point of this but, caller is right, NOT GUILTY.
> =================== CFJ 2945 (Interest Index = 0) ====================
> Removing a decision's adoption index does not count as
> "changing" it for the purpose of Rule 106, and thus cannot be
> done except by taking precedence over Rule 106.
If an Adoption Index is removed, all kinds of odd things happen. For
example, by R2196, it would no longer have any available options.
It's not clear it's possible to do this, and the circumstances under
which it might happen are sufficiently removed from the current ruleset
such that it's tempting to say UNDETERMINED or IRRELEVANT. However,
semantically, it's most reasonable to state that setting an adoption index
to null/no adoption index is in fact a change; and more generally it's
worth stating as a precedent that removing a property from an entity does
in fact count as a "change" of the property for that entity (it might
be possible to make a vague case for this under the last paragraph of
R1586, but it's tenuous so this is just a judgement call on my part,
where the rules are silent). FALSE.
> =================== CFJ 2968 (Interest Index = 0) ====================
> At the time e most recently purported to do so, it was POSSIBLE
> for G. to make ehird Quiet.
Indeed, since the adoption of Proposal 6926 adopted this text:
Each Player is always Noisy, Quiet, or Silent, but never more
than one of these. Whenever a Player posts to a Public Forum,
or a new Player registers, that Player is Noisy.
there was no boot-up procedure, so there's no clear guidance on the
status of players who have not performed one of the above actions.
While "noisy" is listed first, the most reasonable default term to apply
to someone who has not posted is Quiet. So anyone who has not become
noisy since the rule is adopted is either Quiet or (as two weeks have
passed) Silent. FALSE.
> =================== CFJ 2970 (Interest Index = 0) ====================
> It is generally possible for Bucky to register by a means of
> honorable deregistration.
I recuse myself from this case; too close to it. omd, perhaps?
> =================== CFJ 2972 (Interest Index = 0) ====================
> omd is a player.
Took my a second, but reasonably clear in recent context. TRUE.
> =================== CFJ 2974 (Interest Index = 0) ====================
> Viewing the web page http://www.516.ru/ru/ counts as "reading
> the Vladivostok telephone directory".
"Reading" implies some comprehension. A non-Russian speaker could
reasonably transliterate a list of names in Russian alphabet and numbers
beside them. However, that page in particular contains a lot of text
that isn't clear to the non-Russian speaker (presumably describing the
use of the directory) and very few phone numbers, so it in itself is not
sufficient (a link further into this source might be better). But for
this particular exact page, UNDETERMINED (depending on your comprehension
of Russian).
-G.
