On 5/15/22 23:21, secretsnail9 via agora-business wrote: > On Sun, May 15, 2022 at 7:08 PM Edward Murphy via agora-official < > agora-offic...@agoranomic.org> wrote: > >> I resolve elections as follows. Quorum for each is 4. >> >> Arbitor >> Murphy - endorse Jason >> Jason - Jason >> ais523 - Jason >> Madrid - secretsnail >> G. - (Jason, secretsnail) >> Jason 4, secretsnail 1; Jason wins >> >> Prime Minister >> Murphy - (Murphy, nix) >> Jason - (Jason, nix, Murphy, secretsnail, G.) >> ais523 - (Murphy, Jason, nix) >> nix - (nix, Murphy, Jason) >> duck - secretsnail >> Madrid - secretsnail >> G. - (nix, Murphy) >> secretsnail - (secretsnail, nix) >> secretsnail 3, Murphy/nix 2, Jason 1; Jason is eliminated >> nix/secretsnail 3, Murphy 2; Murphy is eliminated >> nix 5, secretsnail 3; nix wins >> >> Registrar >> Murphy - endorse nix >> Jason - endorse nix >> ais523 - nix >> duck - secretsnail >> secretsnail - secretsnail >> nix - (nix, secretsnail) >> Madrid - secretsnail >> G. - (secretsnail, nix) >> nix 4, secretsnail 3; nix wins >> > Note: every voter above has 3 voting strength except for Madrid who has a > voting strength of 2 > > CFJ, submitting to Referee : Jason is the Arbitor, nix is the Prime > Minister, and nix is the Registrar > > Arguments AGAINST: None of the elections contain a "tally" of the voters' > valid ballots, which is necessary for the resolutions to be EFFECTIVE. The > lists of players and their ballots have no sums, and are not even grouped > by what each ballot is, which is hardly a tally. > > CFJ 1710 very clearly sets a precedent that a tally is a sum: > https://github.com/AgoraNomic/cases/blob/6cd01d92c5513424dbe585687357b35d34c80e6d/1710
CFJ 1710 only directly suggests that a sum is sufficient (even when accompanied by an indirect listing), but not that a listing is not also sufficient. Even so, I'd argue that a natural language meaning of "tally" of the ballots includes just listing all of them, and to the extent there is textual ambiguity, game custom heavily suggests this works. -- Jason Cobb Assessor, Rulekeepor, Stonemason
