Alexander Smith wrote: > Pavitra wrote: >> In fact, I think I can get a Win by Paradox out of this. I CFJ on the >> statement: "Warrigal CAN deregister." I believe that eir citizenship >> cannot be determined, and so (since players unambiguously CAN >> deregister, while non-players clearly CANNOT) it is not possible to >> determine whether or not Warrigal CAN deregister. > A self-contradiction is not a paradox.
But it can, sometimes, lead to one. Especially when it's in the rules
rather than, say, a contract.
If you believe that I should not be able to WbP from this, I invite you
to explain exactly why either
1) the statement should be judged something other than UNDETERMINED,
and what judgement should be entered instead;
or
2) my CFJ is not an inquiry case on the possibility or legality of
a rule-defined action (actual or hypothetical, but not arising
from that case itself, and not occurring after the initiation of
that case).
Barring that, I see no basis in the Rules to deny me my Win.
Speaker Pavitra.
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
