--- On Tue, 24/8/10, Ed Murphy <[email protected]> wrote: > OIC. > > Proposal: Mother says not to run on the concrete > (AI = 3, II = 1, co-author = omd, distributable via fee) > > Amend Rule 106 (Adopting Proposals) by replacing this > text: > > If the Rules do not otherwise permit at least one current active > player to distribute a Proposal, then any player may do so > Without 3 Objections. > > with this text: > > If there is a Proposal in the Pool that it would otherwise be > IMPOSSIBLE for any active player to distribute, then any player > CAN distribute that Proposal Without 3 Objections.
Dangerous; the rule currently exists as a safety valve, and it's less of a safety valve in the new version should the pool ever be broken. A more sensible fix would be to make it without-1-objection, and to make it illegal to do so if there would be a better way to make the proposal work (in some more defined sense than just "better"). -- ais523
