scshunt wrote: > On 10-12-19 11:17 PM, Ed Murphy wrote: >> Arguments: "an opinion" can be reasonably interpreted as "exactly one >> opinion", leading to a straightforward judgement of TRUE. > > It can't really. This interpretation is generally unsupported: [snip] > "an" is an existential qualifier. It makes no sense to interpret it as > anything else.
In general, no; but in this particular context, it does make sense, due to (1) obvious intent and (2) implicitly having a "the" applied to it (from "the Justiciar's Opinion").
