Bucky wrote:
On Mon, Dec 5, 2011 at 15:44, Sean Hunt<[email protected]> wrote:
On Sun, Dec 4, 2011 at 12:36, Ed Murphy<[email protected]> wrote:
Detail: http://zenith.homelinux.net/cotc/viewcase.php?cfj=3127
========================= Criminal Case 3127 =========================
Bucky committed the Class-6 Crime of Naughtiness (as defined by
Rule 2356) by publishing the message quoted in evidence.
========================================================================
"Crime" is not defined anywhere in the rules. The English definition,
however, is clear that a crime is a rule violation. So it is certainly
a violation of Rule 2356 to Commit a Crime. All the requirements of a
criminal case are present.
Bucky is not a player, so I judge GUILTY/EXILE so as to prevent em
from registering, as it is the only punishment of any significance to
a non-player.
-scshunt
CfJ (1), inquiry, barring scshunt:
"Scshunt violated a rule with his judgment on the Criminal Case above."
CfJ (2), inquiry, barring scshunt:
"A judgment of EXILE has no effect if the defendant is not a player when
it has been continuously and effectively assigned for a week."
Evidence:
(a) Rule 1054, excerpt: When a judgement of EXILE has been in effect
continuously for
one week,
the ninny is deregistered and CANNOT register for
two months after that time.
(b)Rule 869, excerpt: the verb "to be deregistered" means to cease to be a
player
(i.e., to have one's citizenship changed from Registered to
Unregistered).
Additional Evidence on CfJ (1): the quoted message
Arguments:
From Evidence (a), it is clear that being unable to register is linked to
deregistering. Given the definition of 'deregister' in (b), it is impossible
to deregister someone whose citizenship is not Registered.
Additional Arguments on CfJ (2):
Therefore, Rule 1054's attempt to enforce that "the ninny is deregistered and
CANNOT register for
two months after that time." fails.
Arguments on (2): Rule 1054's "that time" can also reasonably refer to
"a judgement of EXILE has been in effect continuously for one week".
