On Sat, 2016-09-17 at 22:16 +0000, Alexis Hunt wrote:
> Well, rule 591 clearly says that I need only assign a valid judgment. It
> appears, based on my reading, that DISMISS would have been valid but not
> appropriate (whatever that means) while, by a similar implication, TRUE and
> FALSE are both valid and appropriate.

Ah right. So the requirement to assign appropriate judgements ended up
getting repealed at some point, meaning that the judgement itself
doesn't have to correlate with reality (because that's what the
appropriateness requirement was for).


Reply via email to