> Here are the hypotheticals and my answers: These all make sense to me, though I haven't dug too deeply.
I noticed a few things while researching whether ratification can in some sense "change the past". I'll post separately about that, although it looks like the CFJ won't depend on it. > (Incidentally, are the rules clear about when voting strength is determined? > At the time of end of voting period or time of assessment?) I was thinking about this the other day. I think it's time of assessment, based on my interpretation below, though my interpretation could be wrong. * A player's voting strength is a legal fiction that varies over time, much like ownership or switch values. * Rule 955 describes how to calculate the outcome of a decision. The calculation depends on voting strength, so the result of the calculation depends on when you do it. * Rule 955 says "The outcome of a decision is determined when it is resolved". I think that means we should do the calculation at that time. I don't see anything to say the voting strength at the time the vote was cast plays. any role.