On Sun, 2019-07-21 at 21:54 -0400, Jason Cobb wrote:
> On 7/21/19 9:26 PM, [email protected] wrote:
> > (Ugh, I hate top-posting threads, but it's too late to reverse this
> > now.)
>
> I'm sorry, what's a "top-posting thread" and why is it bad?

It's down to how the nested quotes of the messages are ordered. I've
edited this message into "bottom-posting" order; each reply comes below
the message it's replying to, meaning that you can easily see the
context in its appropriate place. When top-posting, each reply comes
/above/ the message it's replying to, so trying to follow the thread
after the fact means you have to jump around in the page.

When bottom-posting, it's also normal to edit the quotes to contain
only the immediately relevant context, so that people can immediately
know what precisely is being replied to (and if you want to reply to
two different points in a message, you split the message at those
points and place the replies immediately below the things they're
replying to). When top-posting, people often forget (because the
message they're replying to is at the bottom and hard to read due to
being out of order), so the quote pyramid often just grows
indefinitely.

Agora used to be exclusively bottom-posted, but there was an influx of
new players a while back whose email clients top-posted by default and
it's lead to a mix of quoting styles being used.

-- 
ais523

Reply via email to