On 8/3/19 2:36 PM, Kerim Aydin wrote:
Not sure I follow? R2140 is P3. R106 "Adopting Proposals" and R2350
"Proposals" are both also P3, so not less. They should be able to set
something to P>3, right? Am I missing something?
On 8/3/2019 12:16 PM, D. Margaux wrote:
> Judged FALSE. NCH voluntarily deregistered less than 30 days ago. Under
> Rule 849, if a player does that, then "e CANNOT register or be
> for 30 days." In my opinion, a proposal "purporting to register nch"
> constitute an attempt to have nch "be registered" less than 30 days
> his voluntary deregistration. That attempt necessarily fails under Rule
Oh, duh. Of course Proposal 8227 won't work to register nch despite
power-3.1, regardless of nch's consent. R106:
Except as prohibited by other rules, a proposal that
takes effect CAN and does, as part of its effect, apply the
changes that it specifies.
R849 clearly prohibits the registration. The "Comptrollor" ban we added
in R2140 recently to prevent lower-powered rules from prohibiting
clauses in higher-powered proposals doesn't apply, because R2140 includes
the "below the power of this rule" qualifier and R849 is power 3.