A draft report follows. -Aris --- I hereby distribute each listed proposal, initiating the Agoran Decision of whether to adopt it, and removing it from the proposal pool. For this decision, the vote collector is the Assessor, the quorum is 4, the voting method is AI-majority, and the valid options are FOR and AGAINST (PRESENT is also a valid vote, as are conditional votes).
ID Author(s) AI Title --------------------------------------------------------------------------- 8280 Murphy, Jason Cobb 3.0 Resolve the troubles v1.1 8281 Gaelan 1.0 Nothing to see here, Rule 1030 v2 8282 Falsifian 1.0 Let's do this the hard way v1.1 8283 Alexis 3.0 Ex Post Ribbon 8284 Alexis 3.0 Line-Item Power 8285 Alexis 3.0 Line-Item Roulette 8286 Aris 1.0 I Forbid Vetos! The proposal pool is currently empty. The full text of the aforementioned proposal(s) is included below. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8280 Title: Resolve the troubles v1.1 Adoption index: 3.0 Author: Murphy Co-authors: Jason Cobb If Proposal 8279 (Equitable Detroubling) has been adopted, then do nothing. Otherwise, ratify the following ~~~-delimited document: ~~~ Each of the following messages was effectively sent via the Public Forum on or about the Date: stamp shown in the archives. Claims within these messages (in particular, claims to perform actions) may still be ineffective for other reasons. Relevant messages from https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-official/2019-December/date.html BUS: Re: OFF: [Treasuror] Forbes 500 James Cook OFF: [Rulekeepor] Short Logical Ruleset Jason Cobb BUS: Re: OFF: [Treasuror] Forbes 500 James Cook OFF: [Promotor] Distribution of Proposal 8277 Aris Merchant OFF: [Registrar] Agoran Directory James Cook OFF: [Registrar] Forbes 500 James Cook OFF: [Rulekeepor] Full Logical Ruleset: October 2019 James Cook OFF: Round 2, fight! Edward Murphy OFF: Fwd: [dicelog] Selection of Comptrollor Edward Murphy OFF: [ADoP] Metareport Edward Murphy OFF: [Distributor] list status omd OFF: [Arbitor] CFJ 3783 Assigned to omd Kerim Aydin OFF: [Registrar] Agoran Directory James Cook OFF: [Treasuror] Forbes 500 James Cook OFF: [Distributor] list status omd Fwd: OFF: [Distributor] list status omd OFF: [ADoP] Metareport Edward Murphy Relevant messages from https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-business/2019-December/date.html BUS: Re: OFF: [Treasuror] Forbes 500 James Cook BUS: Re: OFF: [Treasuror] Forbes 500 James Cook BUS: Re: OFF: [Rulekeepor] Short Logical Ruleset Jason Cobb BUS: Judgement of CFJs 3780 and 3782 James Cook BUS: Judgement of CFJs 3780 and 3782 James Cook BUS: Re: OFF: [Arbitor] CFJ 3779 Assigned to Jason Cobb James Cook DIS: Re: BUS: Re: OFF: [Arbitor] CFJ 3779 Assigned to Jason Cobb James Cook BUS: End of Zombie lease James Cook BUS: Re: [Promotor] Distribution of Proposal 8277 Aris Merchant BUS: Re: OFF: [Registrar] Forbes 500 James Cook BUS: Income James Cook BUS: Re: OFF: [Rulekeepor] Short Logical Ruleset James Cook BUS: Notice of Honour James Cook BUS: Re: OFF: [Promotor] Distribution of Proposal 8277 Edward Murphy BUS: Resolution of Prime Minister election Edward Murphy BUS: Vote on Proposal 8277 James Cook BUS: PM Candidacy James Cook BUS: Might as well try James Cook BUS: Might as well try Jason Cobb BUS: Might as well try omd BUS: CoE on ADoP report James Cook BUS: Notice of Honour James Cook BUS: Re: OFF: [Distributor] list status Aris Merchant BUS: Re: OFF: [Promotor] Distribution of Proposal 8277 Jason Cobb BUS: Favoring Aris Merchant BUS: CoE on ADoP report Edward Murphy BUS: Re: OFF: [ADoP] Metareport Edward Murphy BUS: Income James Cook BUS: Re: OFF: [Rulekeepor] Full Logical Ruleset: October 2019 James Cook BUS: Re: OFF: [Rulekeepor] Short Logical Ruleset James Cook BUS: PM Candidacy James Cook BUS: Re: OFF: [Registrar] Agoran Directory James Cook BUS: End of Zombie lease James Cook BUS: Re: OFF: [Registrar] Agoran Directory James Cook BUS: Re: DIS: [MUD] New Agoran MUD Aris Merchant BUS: Income James Cook BUS: Re: OFF: [Treasuror] Forbes 500 James Cook BUS: I like money too Edward Murphy BUS: PM Candidacy Edward Murphy BUS: PM Candidacy Edward Murphy BUS: PM Candidacy Edward Murphy BUS: I still like money Edward Murphy BUS: PM Candidacy Jason Cobb ~~~ ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8281 Title: Nothing to see here, Rule 1030 v2 Adoption index: 1.0 Author: Gaelan Co-authors: Create a power-0.1 rule titled "Nothing to see here, Rule 1030,” with the following text: { This rule takes precedence over That One Rule, provisions of That One Rule notwithstanding. That One Rule is defined as the rule that Gaelan has most recently declared, by announcement, to be That One Rule. Additionally, this rule takes precedence over all rules other than Rule 1030, provisions of That One Rule notwithstanding. Gaelan CAN, by announcement, award emself the patent title of “The Powerless”. } ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8282 Title: Let's do this the hard way v1.1 Adoption index: 1.0 Author: Falsifian Co-authors: [Begin comment: The purpose is to reduce uncertainty about the status of messages sent while the mailing list was having trouble by undoing most of the actions that happened during that period. I just skimmed the messages on agora-business, agora-official and the backup list that were sent during that period. This doesn't deal with everything: specifically, it doesn't handle: a) the distribution of Proposal 8277 b) the status of the Prime Minister election c) the judge of CFJ 3783 (the Arbitor attempted to recuse twg from CFJ 3783 and assign it to omd during the outage) d) self-ratification of reports Hopefully these can be handled separately, and (d) may stop being an issue once future reports self-ratify. Conditionally setting Comptrollor to vacant isn't an exact reversal, but hopefully shouldn't be too controversial. Some other uncertainties should hopefully go away as reports self-ratify. If not, we can handle them separately. In particular: 1. I wasn't sure what to do about Proposal 8277's possible distribution, and 2. reports may have self-ratified during that period. end comment] Within the text of this proposal, The Troubles is defined as the period starting at 00:15 UTC on Dec 14, 2019 and ending at 01:45 UTC on Dec 28, 2019. Destroy any Coins that were earned during The Troubles and/or as rewards for documents published during The Troubles. Reverse any changes to Karma that happened during The Troubles. If the Officeholder of Comptroller has not changed since the end of The Troubles, set it to vacant. Destroy any CFJs created during The Troubles. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8283 Title: Ex Post Ribbon Adoption index: 3.0 Author: Alexis Co-authors: Amend rule 2438 (Ribbons) by changing "When a proposal is adopted and changes at least one rule with Power >= 3, its proposer earns a Red Ribbon." to "When a proposal is adopted and changes at least one rule that, immediately before or after the change, has Power >= 3, its proposer earns a Red Ribbon." ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8284 Title: Line-Item Power Adoption index: 3.0 Author: Alexis Co-authors: Change the power of Rule 2597 (Line-Item Veto) to 3. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8285 Title: Line-Item Roulette Adoption index: 3.0 Author: Alexis Co-authors: Amend Rule 2518 (Determinacy) by adding a new paragraph reading "The above notwithstanding, any information defined by the rules as indeterminate is indeterminate to the extent specified by the rules." Amend Rule 2597 (Line-Item Veto) by appending "For the purposes of evaluating conditional votes, it is indeterminate whether any provision of any proposal has been vetoed." to the final paragraph. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8286 Title: I Forbid Vetos! Adoption index: 1.0 Author: Aris Co-authors: Repeal Rule 2597, "Line-item Veto". //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
