Rule 991 states:

>       At any time, each CFJ is either open (default), suspended, or
>       assigned exactly one judgement.


What exactly does it mean for a CFJ to be "assigned exactly one
judgement"? Specifically, does this include judgements that are not
listed as "valid judgements" by Rule 591, such as UNDETERMINED? If it
does not, then we potentially have a situation where every CFJ that
doesn't have a judgement listed in the current rules reverts back to
being either open or suspended, which might be a mess to untangle.

Potentially relevant: CFJ 3638 [0], which found that something that is
not a "valid Notice of Honour" can nevertheless be a "Notice of Honour".


[0]: https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3638

-- 
Jason Cobb

  • DIS: On old CFJs Jason Cobb via agora-discussion

Reply via email to