On 2020-05-31 16:00, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus via
agora-discussion wrote:
I have my own thoughts on this case and will make an independent
judgement, but I would appreciate if the Honorable Treasuror could
provide any thoughts they have given that it pertains to switches e
tracks.
Under the unmooted judgement of CFJ 3831 this would probably work due to
the similarity to previous Agoran economic systems. If it were up to me
completely, I would probably say that these transfers failed because in
3831, the context of a Notice of Honour was clear and the logical jump
to karma instead of kudos was easier to make. In this case, however, an
argument could probably be made that many currencies could take the
place of "shiny" in this message.
Maybe that's a half-baked defense. I don't know. It just feels
distinctly wrong to me to consider old terms for similar-looking things
generally synonymous with their new terms.
That being said, I don't actually have a very strong opinion on this
case. Do whatever makes most sense to you.
--
Trigon
