On Sun, 2026-09-06 at 16:33 -0400, Mischief via agora-discussion wrote:
> On 9/6/26 1:22 PM, ais523 via agora-discussion wrote:
> > I think this is along the right lines, but not quite there: there are
> > some conditions that most players can bring about pretty much any time
> > (such as the "exactly 7 number cards" one) but won't naturally fulfil
> > most of the time. So you still get into a timing snipe war (not as to
> > who can call bingo the fastest, but as to who can bring about the easy-
> > but-not-continuously-true requirements the fastest).
> 
> So a player misses out on a win because e was getting close, another event 
> in eir pattern gets satisfied, but e didn't have the 
> easy-but-not-continuously-true condition satisfied? I don't see that as a 
> real problem. Under the assumption that e could have acted to fulfill it but 
> didn't, I'd say that's on em -- e knew (or could have known) e was getting 
> close and would potentially need that condition too.

Well, when you called bingo, I was missing only "boulder at 0" (which
had come very close a few times recently) and "7 types of number card"
(which I could have achieved trivially at any point, having more than 7
and the ability to trade them away). The last time the boulder was at
0, I was missing "another player wins".

In this particular case, I could have figured out that Galle was on the
verge of winning and stashed some Number Cards somewhere safe, but it
would have basically been a timing snipe (because although I knew Galle
was close to winning, I didn't know the exact timing). So it would have
come down to timing if not for the boulder being in the wrong place.

I would have been quite capable of the timing snipe (in fact, I posted
a message relevant to Galle's win immediately after e first attempted
it), but it still seems undesirable to me that the timing snipe could
have been beneficial even though it wouldn't have been an obstacle to
me in particular. 

-- 
ais523

Reply via email to