Voting results for Proposals 6648 - 6668:
[This notice resolves the Agoran decisions of whether to adopt the
following proposals. For each decision, the options available to
Agora are ADOPTED (*), REJECTED (x), and FAILED QUORUM (!).]
[Exception: I'm pretty sure "6653" wasn't actually a proposal -
did the Promotor ever respond to the CoE? - but if it was, then its
voting period was extended for lack of quorum, so I vote 1xAGAINST
and resolve it as failing.]
*6648 OR1 1.0 Yally Better Degree Awarding
x6649 OP1 2.0 coppro Old and Outdated Winning Conditions
*6650 OP1 3.0 coppro Contract Cleanup
*6651 OR1 2.0 coppro PRESENT cleanup
x6652 OR1 1.0 coppro Sdupid Mistake Day
6653 OR0 1.0 Yally Criminalize Gaming the System
*6654 OG1 2.0 Murphy House Un-Agoran Activities Committee
*6655 OP0 3.0 comex this rule is useless
*6656 OP1 3.0 coppro Proposal Power Pilfering Program
*6657 OG1 2.0 Murphy Fix Winning and Losing Conditions
*6658 OG0 1.0 Murphy Fix Renaissance
*6659 OG0 2.0 Murphy Fix Clout
*6660 OG0 2.0 Murphy Consolidate time definitions
*6661 OG0 3.0 Murphy Yellow ribbons are pointless, and ...
*6662 OG0 2.0 Murphy Maternal courage
x6663 OG0 2.0 Murphy Deny quorum without math tricks
*6664 OG0 1.0 Murphy Clarify eye-hurt
*6665 OG0 2.0 Murphy s/if not/unless/
*6666 OG1 2.0 Murphy Slow down activity-related wins
*6667 OG1 2.0 Murphy Budget cut
x6668 OG1 2.0 Murphy Legislative and judicial salaries
6648 6649 6650 6651 6652 6653 6654 6655 6656 6657
ais523 F 2A 2F F P A 5A 2F 2F 5A
allispaul A 2A 2F F F 5P 2F 2F 5F
comex 2F 5A 5F 2F 2A 2A A 5F 5F A
coppro 3P 7F 7F 3F 3F 3A F 7F 7F F
Murphy F 2A 2F F P A 5F 2F 2F 5F
Tiger P 2F 2F F F P 5F 2F 2F 5F
Yally 2F 5A 5F 2F 4A F 5P 5P F
AI 1 2 3 2 1 1 2 3 3 2
VI 6 0.5+ *U* *U* 0.8+ 0 2 *U* *U* 2.8+
F/A 6/1 9/16 25/0 11/0 5/6 0/7 12/6 20/0 20/0 17/6
Quorum 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5
Voters 7 7 7 7 7 4 7 7 7 7
6658 6659 6660 6661 6662 6663 6664 6665 6666 6667
ais523 5A 5F 5A 5F 5A 5A 5F 5F 5A 5F
allispaul 5F 5F 5P 5F 5F 5A 5F 5F 5F 5A
comex A F A F A A F F A F
coppro F F F F F F F F A A
Murphy 5F 5F 5F 5F 5F 5F 5F 5F 5F 5F
Tiger 5F 5F 5F 5F 5F 5F 5F 5F 5F 5F
Yally F F F F F A F F F A
AI 1 2 2 3 2 2 1 2 2 2
VI 2.8+ *U* 2 *U* 2.8+ 0.9+ *U* *U* 2.2+ 2.2+
F/A 17/6 23/0 12/6 23/0 17/6 11/12 23/0 23/0 16/7 16/7
Quorum 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5
Voters 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7
6668
ais523 5A
allispaul 5F
comex A
coppro F
Murphy 5F
Tiger 5A
Yally A
AI 2
VI 0.9+
F/A 11/12
Quorum 5
Voters 7
Text of adopted proposals:
---------------------------------------------------------------------
ID: 6648
Title: Better Degree Awarding
Author: Yally
AI: 1.0
II: 1
Chamber: Red
Amend Rule 1367 (Degrees) in the following ways:
Change the text reading:
- Each player's voting limit on the decision is three, plus five
for each
degree e held at that time (the high limit is so as to allow
a player to cast votes for different titles and ensure that
an inappropriate title is not awarded).
to read:
- Each player's voting limit on the decision is one.
Add the following text to the bulleted list:
- Rules to the contrary notwithstanding, the outcome of the
decision is the highest degree such that more than half of the
valid votes selected that degree or a lower degree. If no such
degree exists, the outcome is FAILING GRADE.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ID: 6650
Title: Contract Cleanup
Author: coppro
AI: 3.0
II: 1
Chamber: Purple
Amend, in the order in which they are specified in this proposal, Rules
1728 (Dependent Actions), Rule 2166 (Assets), Rule 1586 (Definition and
Continuity of Entities) by removing each instance of "or contract" and
of "or contracts".
Amend Rule 2166 (Assets) by deleting the last paragraph.
Amend Rule 754 (Definition Definitions) by deleting "followed by
definitions used in contracts or other Agoran legal documents,".
If Rule 2263 (Acting On Behalf) has not been repealed, amend it by
removing the last bullet.
If Rule 2199 (Ribbons) has not been repealed, amend it by removing the
last bullet.
Repeal Rule 2285 (Contracts).
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ID: 6651
Title: PRESENT cleanup
Author: coppro
AI: 2.0
II: 1
Chamber: Red
In rule 2154 (Election Procedure), delete the text:
If the number of candidates falls below two,
PRESENT ceases to be a valid option.
as Rule 693 provides for PRESENT.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ID: 6654
Title: House Un-Agoran Activities Committee
Author: Murphy
AI: 2.0
II: 1
Chamber: Green
Amend Rule 2255 (Cards) by appending this text to the first paragraph:
Ownership of cards is restricted to players.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ID: 6655
Title: this rule is useless
Author: c.
AI: 3.0
II: 0
Chamber: Purple
Repeal Rule 2263 (Acting on Behalf).
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ID: 6656
Title: Proposal Power Pilfering Program
Author: coppro
AI: 3.0
II: 1
Chamber: Purple
Amend rule 106 (Adopting Proposals) by replacing:
When creating proposals, the person who creates them SHOULD
ensure that the proposal outlines changes to be made to Agora,
such as enacting, repealing, or amending rules, or making other
explicit changes to the gamestate. When a proposal that includes
such explicit changes takes effect, those changes are applied to
the gamestate.
with
When creating proposals, the person who creates them SHOULD
ensure that the proposal outlines changes to be made to Agora,
such as enacting, repealing, or amending rules, or making other
explicit changes to the gamestate. When a proposal that includes
such explicit changes takes effect, it applies those changes to
the gamestate. If the proposal cannot make some such changes, this
does not preclude the other changes from taking place.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ID: 6657
Title: Fix Winning and Losing Conditions
Author: Murphy
AI: 2.0
II: 1
Chamber: Green
Amend Rule 2186 (Victory) to read:
Winning Conditions and Losing Conditions are conditions defined
as such by the rules. If such a condition is defined by the
rules as being satisfied when an event occurs (as opposed to
being satisfied while certain other conditions hold), then it
thereafter continues to be satisfied until the rules explicitly
say otherwise.
When one or more persons satisfy at least one Winning Condition
and do not satisfy any Losing Conditions, all such persons win
the game. The game CANNOT be won in any other way, rules to the
contrary notwithstanding.
Each Winning Condition should (if needed) specify a cleanup
procedure to prevent an arbitrary number of wins arising from
essentially the same conditions. When one or more persons win
the game:
a) For each Winning Condition satisfied by at least one of
those persons, its cleanup procedure (if any) occurs.
b) Each of those persons ceases to satisfy any Winning
Conditions.
A win announcement is a factually correct announcement
explicitly labeled as a win announcement and/or clearly stating
that one or more persons win the game.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ID: 6658
Title: Fix Renaissance
Author: Murphy
AI: 1.0
II: 0
Chamber: Green
Amend Rule 2199 (Ribbons) by replacing this text:
If this rule mentions at least six different specific colors for
Ribbons, then a player CAN destroy one Ribbon of each such color
in eir possession to satisfy the Winning Condition of
Renaissance.
with this text:
If this rule mentions at least six different specific colors for
Ribbons, then upon a win announcement that one or more players
each possess at least one Ribbon of each such color, all those
players satisfy the Winning Condition of Renaissance.
Cleanup procedure: For each of those players, one Ribbon of each
such color in eir possession is destroyed.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ID: 6659
Title: Fix Clout
Author: Murphy
AI: 2.0
II: 0
Chamber: Green
Amend Rule 2134 (Win by Clout) by replacing this text:
Cleanup procedure: Each player's caste is set to its default
value, and no player satisfies this Winning Condition again (the
remainder of this rule notwithstanding) during the same month.
with this text:
Cleanup procedure: No player satisfies this Winning Condition
again during the same month, the remainder of this rule
notwithstanding.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ID: 6660
Title: Consolidate time definitions
Author: Murphy
AI: 2.0
II: 0
Chamber: Green
Amend Rule 1023 (Common Definitions) by appending this text after
section (b) (5):
(5) A pivot is either the instant at which Agora Nomic began
(June 30, 1993, 00:04:30 GMT +1200) or an instant at which
at least one person won the game. When used as a period
of time, a "game" is the period of time between a pivot
and the next pivot.
Repeal Rule 2244 (The Games of Agora).
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ID: 6661
Title: Yellow ribbons are pointless, and other contract cleanup
Author: Murphy
AI: 3.0
II: 0
Chamber: Green
Amend Rule 2199 (Ribbons) by removing section (+Y).
[Impossible to earn now that contests have been repealed.]
Amend Rule 2263 (Acting on Behalf).
[Apparently unusable now that contracts have been repealed.]
Amend Rule 2203 (Hawkishness) by replacing the Hugging section
with this text:
* Hugging. Hugging players are unqualified to be assigned as
judge of any criminal case.
[Eliminate dangling reference to equity cases.]
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ID: 6662
Title: Maternal courage
Author: Murphy
AI: 2.0
II: 0
Chamber: Green
Amend Rule 1681 (The Logical Rulesets) by replacing "strongly
encouraged not to include" with "strongly DISCOURAGED from
including", and by replacing "is also free to include" with
"SHOULD also include".
Amend Rule 2246 (Submitting a CFJ to the Justiciar) by replacing
"encouraged" with "ENCOURAGED".
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ID: 6664
Title: Clarify eye-hurt
Author: Murphy
AI: 1.0
II: 0
Chamber: Green
Amend Rule 2143 (Official Reports and Duties) by replacing "Publishing
reports that deviate" with "Publishing a report that deviates".
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ID: 6665
Title: s/if not/unless/
Author: Murphy
AI: 2.0
II: 0
Chamber: Green
Amend Rule 2154 (Election Procedure) by replacing section 2 with
this text:
2) The eligible voters are the active first-class players,
unless there is an Emergency Session at the time the
decision is initiated, in which case the eligible voters
are the active Senators.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ID: 6666
Title: Slow down activity-related wins
Author: Murphy
AI: 2.0
II: 1
Chamber: Green
Amend Rule 2130 (Activity) by appending this text:
Having been inactive within the past week is a Losing Condition.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ID: 6667
Title: Budget cut
Author: Murphy
AI: 2.0
II: 1
Chamber: Green
Amend Rule 2138 (The Intergalactic Associate Director of Personnel)
by replacing "Intergalactic" with "Interplanetary" in its title and
text.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
