RESOLUTION OF PROPOSALS 9202-9210
=================================
ID Title Result
---------------------------------------------
9202 Track Assets ADOPTED
9203 A clarification ADOPTED
9204 Rare stamps, more differently ADOPTED
9205 Switch It Up ADOPTED
9206 Let Contracts Own Stamps ADOPTED
9207 (n/a) REJECTED
9208 Destroy the Office ADOPTED
9209 Goblins? REJECTED
9210 Gnomes? REJECTED
I hereby resolve the Agoran decisions to adopt the below proposals.
The quorum for all below decisions was 5.
VOTING STRENGTHS
================
Strength is 3 unless otherwise noted.
#: player has voting strength 3
$: player has voting strength 4
%: player has voting strength 5
^: player has voting strength 6
PROPOSALS
=========
PROPOSAL 9202 (Track Assets)
AUTHOR: Murphy
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (7): 4st, Janet^, Kate%, Mischief^, Murphy^, ais523%, snail^
AGAINST (0):
PRESENT (2): juan%, sprock
BALLOTS: 9
AI (F/A): 37/0 (AI=1.0)
POPULARITY: 0.778
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
PROPOSAL 9203 (A clarification)
AUTHOR: Janet
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (9): 4st, Janet^, Kate%, Mischief^, Murphy^, ais523%, juan%, snail^, sprock
AGAINST (0):
PRESENT (0):
BALLOTS: 9
AI (F/A): 45/0 (AI=2.0)
POPULARITY: 1.000
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
PROPOSAL 9204 (Rare stamps, more differently)
AUTHOR: Janet
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (5): 4st, Janet^, Mischief^, Murphy^, snail^
AGAINST (2): Kate%, ais523%
PRESENT (2): juan%, sprock
BALLOTS: 9
AI (F/A): 27/10 (AI=1.0)
POPULARITY: 0.333
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Murphy: Mischief is the Collector: Endorsement of Mischief
]
PROPOSAL 9205 (Switch It Up)
AUTHOR: Mischief
CLASS: DEMOCRATIC
FOR (7): 4st, Kate, Mischief, Murphy, juan, snail, sprock
AGAINST (0):
PRESENT (2): Janet, ais523
BALLOTS: 9
AI (F/A): 21/0 (AI=3.0)
POPULARITY: 0.778
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Janet: Endorsement of ais523
]
PROPOSAL 9206 (Let Contracts Own Stamps)
AUTHOR: Mischief
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (7): 4st, Kate%, Mischief^, Murphy^, ais523%, juan%, sprock
AGAINST (1): Janet^
PRESENT (1): snail^
BALLOTS: 9
AI (F/A): 33/6 (AI=1.0)
POPULARITY: 0.667
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
PROPOSAL 9207 ((n/a))
AUTHOR: 4st
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (2): 4st, juan%
AGAINST (7): Janet^, Kate%, Mischief^, Murphy^, ais523%, snail^, sprock
PRESENT (0):
BALLOTS: 9
AI (F/A): 8/37 (AI=1.0)
POPULARITY: -0.556
OUTCOME: REJECTED
PROPOSAL 9208 (Destroy the Office)
AUTHOR: 4st
CLASS: DEMOCRATIC
FOR (6): 4st, Janet, Kate, Mischief, ais523, juan
AGAINST (1): snail
PRESENT (2): Murphy, sprock
BALLOTS: 9
AI (F/A): 18/3 (AI=1.0)
POPULARITY: 0.556
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Murphy: Geologist is vacant: Inextricable
juan: Endorsement of 4st
]
PROPOSAL 9209 (Goblins?)
AUTHOR: 4st
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (4): 4st, Mischief^, Murphy^, juan%
AGAINST (4): Janet^, Kate%, ais523%, snail^
PRESENT (1): sprock
BALLOTS: 9
AI (F/A): 20/22 (AI=1.0)
POPULARITY: 0.000
OUTCOME: REJECTED
PROPOSAL 9210 (Gnomes?)
AUTHOR: 4st
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (4): 4st, Mischief^, Murphy^, juan%
AGAINST (4): Janet^, Kate%, ais523%, snail^
PRESENT (1): sprock
BALLOTS: 9
AI (F/A): 20/22 (AI=1.0)
POPULARITY: 0.000
OUTCOME: REJECTED
The full text of each ADOPTED proposal is included below:
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 9202
Title: Track Assets
Adoption index: 1.0
Author: Murphy
Co-authors:
Amend Rule 2692 (Bang!) by replacing "Bangs are a fungible asset." with
"Bangs are an untracked fungible asset."
Retitle Rule 2603 (Switch Responsibility) to "Default Recordkeepors",
and amend it by replacing "switch" with "switch or asset".
[Unchanged from proto. Encourages assets intended to be untracked to be
explicitly labeled as such, otherwise materializes an officer, both in
the same fashion as switches.]
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 9203
Title: A clarification
Adoption index: 2.0
Author: Janet
Co-authors: ais523
Amend Rule 991 ("Calls for Judgement") by appending the following to the
first paragraph: "A case so initiated is an inquiry case."
["inquiry case" is a historical term used for a CFJ on the truth of a
statement. It has a few remaining uses in the rules. Defining it here
removes any ambiguity and helps answer a question that has been asked
multiple times by newer players. This is careful to not redefine "CFJ"
itself, which might affect past CFJs.]
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 9204
Title: Rare stamps, more differently
Adoption index: 1.0
Author: Janet
Co-authors:
Amend Rule 2701 ("Stamp Scamp") to read, in whole:
{
A rare stamp is a stamp that is the only one of its type that exists.
Stamp scamp is a singleton switch tracked by the Collector with possible
values of each player and null (default). Upon a correct announcement
that a specified player owns more rare stamps than any other player, the
stamp scamp switch is flipped to that player.
If no person has done so by this mechanism in this quarter, the value of
the stamp scamp switch, if a player, CAN by announcement cause another
specified player to gain one stamp of that player's type.
}
If exactly one player holds the patent title of Stamp Scamp, the stamp
scamp switch is hereby flipped to that player.
The patent title "Stamp Scamp" is hereby revoked from each player that
holds it.
[Switches are the standard way to track state like this. We shouldn't
use a patent title for this. The current Herald is not actually
reporting, so it will not actually be tracked; the Herald's report
should be used for historical matters, not (new) ephemera; and it will
hand out violet ribbons for very little reason.]
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 9205
Title: Switch It Up
Adoption index: 3.0
Author: Mischief
Co-authors: Janet
[This explicitly allow contracts to define switches. They maybe work
okay anyway, but this puts things on a firmer foundation. The "secured"
definition is deliberately left referencing Rules only, as a contract
doesn't have power.
I considered amending the third paragraph of rule 2698 (Recordkeepors),
but contracts have plenty of flexibility to impose any desired reporting
requirements for their switches (or to leave them untracked).]
Amend rule 2162 (Switches) by making the following replacements, in order:
1) Replace:
A type of switch is a property that the rules define as a switch,
and specify the following:
with:
A type of switch is a property that a rule or a contract defines
as a switch (with such rule or contract being its backing
document) and specifies the following:
2) Replace:
If a type of switch is not explicitly designated as
possibly-indeterminate by the rule that defines it, and if an
action or set of actions would cause the value of an instance of
that type of switch to become indeterminate, that instance instead
takes on its last determinate and possible value, if any,
otherwise it takes on its default value.
with:
If a type of switch is not explicitly designated as
possibly-indeterminate by its backing document, and if an action
or set of actions would cause the value of an instance of that
type of switch to become indeterminate, that instance instead
takes on its last determinate and possible value, if any,
otherwise it takes on its default value.
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 9206
Title: Let Contracts Own Stamps
Adoption index: 1.0
Author: Mischief
Co-authors:
Amend rule 2659 (Stamps) by replacing:
Stamps are a category of asset ownable by players.
with:
Stamps are a category of asset ownable by players and contracts.
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 9208
Title: Destroy the Office
Adoption index: 1.0
Author: 4st
Co-authors:
Amend Crystals (Rule 2685) by replacing:
"The Geologist is a sortitioned office that tracks crystals."
with:
"Crystals are untracked."
and replacing:
"Once a quarter, the Geologist CAN (and SHALL during its first
Eastman week) publish a Notice of Crystal Growth, upon which each
crystal whose identity is not equal to the ID of any rule in the
current ruleset has its size increased by 3."
with:
"At the beginning of each quarter, all crystals whose identity is not equal
to the ID of any rule in the current ruleset has its size increased by 3."
If this proposal is democratic, repeal Crystals (Rule 2685).
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
