On Mon, Sep 14, 2009 at 12:41, Sean Hunt <[email protected]> wrote: > Roger Hicks wrote: >> >> On Sun, Sep 13, 2009 at 13:34, Charles Walker >> <[email protected]> wrote: >>> >>> I publish a NoV accusing BobTHJ of violating Rule 2143, a Power 1 >>> Rule, by publishing an Anarchist's report on the 10th of September, >>> 2009 claiming that C-walker does not own any cards from the Deck of >>> Change. I contest this NoV and initiate a criminal case from it. >>> >> Arguments: My report does clearly state (in the history section) that >> C-Walker's current holdings are in dispute. I recommend NOT GUILTY. >> >> BobTHJ >> _______________________________________________ >> Agora mailing list >> [email protected] >> http://listserver.tue.nl/mailman/listinfo/agora > > I do not see that anywhere. Searching for C-walker's name shows nowhere in > the report that indicates eir holdings may be ambiguous.
You're right, I apologize. C-Walker's self-audit (which shows the disputed disclaimer) was not properly tagged to appear on that report. I will fix that error. > > Note that officers are not as a matter of course expected to put disclaimers > at the top of their reports, rather, they are required not to put inaccurate > or misleading. When the game state seems to be truly ambiguous (and not that > it is merely subject to an interpretation and thus is in one of a certain > number of states), it is, in my opinion, criminal misconduct to attempt to > ratify that the player in question has no cards. Publishing instead that eir > number of cards is unknown is completely permissible, as it is accurate and > not misleading; failing to indicate that e has cards at all is both > inaccurate in all probability, as well as misleading. > It was not my intent to publish misleading information, and I did not simply ignore the dispute and omit C-Walker from the list because eir holdings were in dispute. Instead I published what I believe to be the correct gamestate (based on the cards Tiger randomly selected to be destroyed as the result of audit and C-Walker's subsequent plays - e would have had no Change or Justice cards remaining). BobTHJ _______________________________________________ Agora mailing list [email protected] http://listserver.tue.nl/mailman/listinfo/agora
