-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 How about for #2: "If an SVN commit corresponds to multiple Jira tasks, then list all that apply in the commit message."
Marlon On 9/16/11 3:48 PM, Suresh Marru wrote: > > On Sep 16, 2011, at 2:55 PM, Marlon Pierce wrote: > > As you should know, Jira can show SVN commits that are associated with a > particular issue: just put the issue number in the commit message. See for > example Airavata-93. I have two proposals: > > 1. I propose that every SVN commit be associated with specific (and closable) > Jira tasks. >> + 1, I think we should really do this, among others things, looking at JIRA >> will give a good picture of where one can volunteer. > > 2. While it is possible for Jira to handle multiple task definitions in a > single commit message (like "(AIRAVATA-99)(AIRAVATA-100)(AIRAVATA-101) fixing > lots of bugs...."), I propose we should under normal circumstances only > associate one Jira task with each commit. > >> + 0. I think this will be ideal, but may be harder to achieve. I will say + >> 1 for this approach if we literally take into account "under normal >> circumstances" clause. There will be cases where one commit might address >> few issues, but as much as possible we should shoot for one on one svn >> commit vs JIRA. There might be multiple commits to address one JIRA, but at >> least in the initial phases of development and integration, we might have >> multiple mappings. > >> But nevertheless, I will say many +1's for fist proposal. Every commit >> should at least have one JIRA associated. > >> Suresh > > This will help us easily keep track of changes between release versions, for > example. > > > Marlon > -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG/MacGPG2 v2.0.16 (Darwin) Comment: Using GnuPG with Mozilla - http://enigmail.mozdev.org/ iQEcBAEBAgAGBQJOc6wsAAoJEEfVXEODPFIDfF8H/ihXrazNiet7PnDCTHVJgIW4 kMUmNSTqJcOUlFTFry7NDOF31/u4zAp/wQc+8J/7Wni5hjbtg27fm/OewHwJfiGk xE+6oZufewd81i/XdupFVtFI2uCeLrAs1mrVXOEBoUL1WqCgh+lS/1tcuhbKWWbS 6WVzl52WVGALfRoxbS+TOLjAtDtrZA2vC3L3MDe+lC5Fcn6FXdwjEfI4kVslPovl 0e6xRgi9W72jCB/q3+oV+EN0GXDsEaBIhW3I3AXpVdbiYlzufRxXmpa1kW7jAZ8d GXPrvNaKa1gcK2FcyDtizM86gnwvEGC6tOqM5VHzKBOfNcLaU7yIZwCkcbfNhE8= =QE05 -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
