Here's what Donald Sparling said when I emailed him:

I'll send you reprints of the articles we have published on methoprene.
With regards to frogs, several years ago we examined frogs coming from a
set of experimental wetlands - sprayed with Altosid, Abate or Controls.
Abate (active ingredient temephos) sprayed wetlands had significantly fewer
tadpoles than either controls or Altosid. Altosid ponds had higher
frequencies of malformed tadpoles including many with missing hindlimbs,
portions of hindlimbs or entire halves of pelvic girdles. We did not look
for parasites because the study occurred prior to that link being known.
Subsequent attempts to confirm that study met with confounding problems.The data to 
date are somewhat contradictory and there is no
unequivocal relationship between Altosid and amphibian malformations

Anita E. Cook 
Aquatic Wildlife Program Staff Specialist 
Fisheries Bureau 
Nevada Department of Wildlife 
1100 Valley Road 
Reno, NV   89512 
775-688-1532 
[EMAIL PROTECTED]



-----Original Message-----
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Friday, May 21, 2004 11:34 AM
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Cc: Anita Cook; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: Re: [akherps] Herps (and fish and shellfish, etc) and Mosquito
Spraying



Fred-

I think Don would be a good resource.  He can be reached at:

Don Sparling
Cooperative Wildlife Research Center
MS 6504, Life Sciences II
Southern Illinois University
Carbondale, IL 62901
phone:  618-453-6949
fax:  618-453-6944

Sherry Krest
USFWS, CBFO
177 Admiral Cochrane Dr.
Annapolis, MD 21401
P: 410-573-4525
F: 410-269-0832
[EMAIL PROTECTED]


                                                                                       
              
                      Fred Pinkney                                                     
              
                                               To:      Sherry 
Krest/CBFO/R5/FWS/[EMAIL PROTECTED],            
                      05/21/2004 01:55         [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED]    
               
                      PM                       cc:      Mike J 
Higgins/CBFO/R5/FWS/[EMAIL PROTECTED]           
                                               Subject: Re: [akherps] Herps (and fish 
and shellfish, 
                                               etc) and Mosquito Spraying              
              
                                                                                       
              



Sherry,
Do you want to refer this person to Don Sparling?  I don't have his contact
info.  I think he might be best.  What I would say at this point, is that
no one has established a smoking gun for altosid and frog impacts but you
may want Don's perspective.  As far as other pesticides, we know that abate
(temephos) is highly toxic to non-target insects and that mosquitoes are
also developing resistance.  I am not aware of any studies on the effects
of Bti on amphibians.

Fred Pinkney
410-573-4519
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
----- Forwarded by Fred Pinkney/CBFO/R5/FWS/DOI on 05/21/2004 01:49 PM
-----
                                                                                       
              
                      Deborah Rudis                                                    
              
                                               To:      [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]          
                      05/21/2004 01:08         cc:      Fred 
Pinkney/CBFO/R5/FWS/[EMAIL PROTECTED]             
                      PM                       Subject: Re: [akherps] Herps (and fish 
and shellfish, 
                                               etc) and Mosquito Spraying(Document 
link: Fred        
                                               Pinkney)                                
              
                                                                                       
              



Anita - contact Dr. Fred Pinkney @ USFWS in Annapolis, MD.   I believe he
may have some info on this subject
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Deborah D. Rudis
US Fish & Wildlife Service
Ecological Services Field Office
3000 Vintage Blvd. #201
Juneau, Alaska  99801

907/586-7648   fax 907/586-7154
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


                                                                                       
              
                      "Anita Cook"                                                     
              
                      <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>         To:      <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, 
"Discussions Related  
                      Sent by:                 to Monitoring Amphibians" <[EMAIL 
PROTECTED]>,     
                      [EMAIL PROTECTED]         "Amy Lind" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, 
"Bridget Nielsen"    
                      ikine.org                <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Chad Mellison"    
        
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Chambers UNR"     
       
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Cynthia Martinez" 
               
                      05/19/2004 05:34         <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Dave Bradford"    
    
                      PM                       <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Douglas R Clarke" 
 
                      Please respond           <[EMAIL PROTECTED]'>, "Dr. Richard 
Tracy"             
                      to akherps               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Elisabeth Ammon"  
    
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Gary Juenger"     
                 
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Genny Wilson"     
       
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Glenn Clemmer"    
             
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Jaime Schoneberg" 
       
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Jenni Jeffers"    
   
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Jessica Rudden"   
              
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Jim Harvey"       
     
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Kent Hatch"       
            
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Kent McAdoo"      
             
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Lynn Zimmerman"   
      
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Michael 
Burroughs"     
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Michelle Koo"     
   
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Roland Knapp"     
            
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Anita Cook 
(E-mail)"       
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Bob Layton 
(E-mail)"    
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Chris Drake 
(E-mail)"            
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Glenn Clemmer 
(E-mail)"           
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Jennifer Newmark  
   
                                               (E-mail)" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Kent 
McAdoo    
                                               (E-mail)" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Laurie 
Sada        
                                               (E-mail)" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Mark 
Maley          
                                               (E-mail)" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Randy 
McNatt      
                                               (E-mail)" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Ray 
Lister      
                                               (E-mail)" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Rich 
Haskins      
                                               (E-mail)" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Sarah   
   
                                               Newman - BLM" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, 
"Will Amy    
                                               (E-mail)" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Amy Van 
Donk"            
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Bill Bosworth"    
          
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Bob Williams 
(E-mail)" 
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Bonnie Hunt"      
        
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Brad Bauman 
(E-mail)"         
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Brian Ferebee"    
           
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Bryce Maxell"     
             
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Carmen Bailey"    
      
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Chris Funk"       
          
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Christopher 
Pearl"         
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Chuck Harris"     
     
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Clinton McCarthy" 
       
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Cynthia Tait"     
          
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "David Pilliod"    
        
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Dorothy Mason"    
         
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Doug Clarke 
(E-mail)"    
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Dwayne K. 
Winslow"              
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Eric Simandle"    
             
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Georgina Lampman" 
               
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Greg Smith"       
             
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Hallie Lingo"     
             
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Jake Sellman"     
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Jay Bowerman"     
        
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Jim Clark"        
            
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Jim Marble 
(E-mail)"            
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Jim Munger"       
            
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Jon C. Sjoberg"   
         
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Karolee Owens"    
               
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Krissy Wilson"    
          
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Lance Brown"      
          
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Larry Michaels"   
             
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Laura Todd"       
     
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Maija Meneks"     
             
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Marianne 
Crawford"              
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Mattie Allen"     
      
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Mike Mathis"      
               
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Portia Jelinek"   
            
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Rhen Etzelmiller" 
             
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Rich Howard"      
            
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Rick Hardy"       
            
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Signe 
Sather-Blair"            
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Steve Yundt"      
     
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Ted Koch"         
         
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Todd Hogrefe"     
               
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Tom Skiles 
(E-mail)"   
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Wendy Wente"      
               
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "William LeVere"   
           
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Yvonne Dettlaff"  
              
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Dawn Grabowski 
(E-mail)"  
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Diane Wong 
(E-mail)"       
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Kim Tisdale 
(E-mail)"              
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Mike Sevon 
(E-mail)"    
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Adam R. Backlin"  
        
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Alex L. Heindl"   
              
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Ann D Carlson"    
               
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Carlos Davidson"  
            
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Cathy Brown"      
             
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Cindy Hitchcock"  
           
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Deborah Cowman"   
            
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Foung Vang"       
              
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Gary M. Fellers"  
         
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Gayle Garman"     
  
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "HOWARD R PANIK 
(E-mail)"       
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Jacob Martin"     
                 
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Jef Jaeger"       
           
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Jeff Angermann"   
       
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Kevin 
Emmerich/Laura      
                                               Cunningham" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, 
"Michael Graf"    
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Michael J Adams 
(E-mail)"          
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Paul Obert"       
               
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Raul Rodriguez"   
         
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Robert Stack"     
                
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Robert W. Hansen" 
      
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Ross Haley 
(E-mail)"          
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Suzin J. Romin"   
             
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Tracy Fredin"     
            
                                               <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>                     
              
                                               cc:                                     
              
                                               Subject: [akherps] Herps (and fish and 
shellfish,     
                                               etc) and Mosquito Spraying              
              
                                                                                       
              




I apologize for any cross-postings - I wanted to reach as wide an audience
as possible....

I received a call from someone with a Nevada state agency that wants to
know potential impacts of anti-mosquito pellets on amphibians (and any
other aquatics of concern).  With West Nile Virus (WNV) in the news in the
last year, it's an issue that I imagine other states may be grappling with.

The product that might be used is Altosid, which contains methoprene, an
insect growth regulator.  The product ads say it doesn't interfere with the
food chain, nor impact fish or other non-target species - won't harm the
environment (http://www.altosid.com/).  Does anyone have any further
information on this product, including any information on impacts on
amphibians at different life stages, or on other organisms that might be in
the same areas, such as beneficial insects/larvae, freshwater mussels,
native fish, etc.?  The person that called me said that she would send me
some references about potential impacts to amphibians.

Mosquito control is an important issue, especially where WNV has been
detected (not reported in Nevada yet).  Is this the best alternative?   We
all know that amphibians do their part, and I was considering suggesting
bat houses as a companion "treatment".  I was asked about gambusia
(mosquitofish), and I know that some Nevada counties are using them for
mosquito control, but they have their own set of environmental impacts,
especially where they can interfere with our native fish.

Here are some additional web sites I found:

http://www.ci.nyc.ny.us/html/doh/html/wnv/wnvfaq6.html
http://www.jamestownnd.com/vectorcontrol/altosid_chemical_label.htm

**** Study on  methoprene - potential link to increased abnormalities:
http://www.pwrc.usgs.gov/research/sis2000/sparl07.htm    (I've emailed the
person listed as the study lead)
http://www.the-piedpiper.co.uk/th13(q).htm

Resmethrin vs Bti vs Altosid
http://www.town.sudbury.ma.us/services/health/emmcp/infoareanew.htm


http://www.epa.gov/pesticides/factsheets/skeeters.htm





I'll be looking more into some of these and other websites, but thought
that it would be very good to get feedback from the biological community.


Anita E. Cook
Aquatic Wildlife Program Staff Specialist
Fisheries Bureau
Nevada Department of Wildlife
1100 Valley Road
Reno, NV   89512
775-688-1532
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

















Reply via email to