With aerial deposition of many pesticides into AK from areas far away, perhaps we are seeing this phenomena????
-ddr



Scientist hip-hops into frog mystery. Relyea and his baby frogs are
upending widely held beliefs about pesticide safety. Pittsburgh
Tribune-Review, Pennsylvania. [related stories]
http://pittsburghlive.com/x/tribune-review/trib/regional/s_205757.html

Scientist hip-hops into frog mystery
By Jennifer Bails
Pittsburgh TRIBUNE-REVIEW
Friday, July 30, 2004
SOUTH SHENANGO -- For lack of a better name, they call it The Farm.

Drive about two hours north of Pittsburgh, cross over the carp-crammed
spillway at Pymatuning Reservoir to an unmarked dirt road, and you will
stumble upon this 130-acre tract of converted swampland.

There, under a wide open sky, thousands of tadpoles wiggle in murky,
algae-encrusted tubs, unaware that their fate is in the hands of University
of Pittsburgh biology professor Rick Relyea.

The Farm is an outpost of Pitt's Pymatuning Laboratory of Ecology, a field
research station in Crawford County where Relyea and his baby frogs are
upending widely held beliefs about pesticide safety. Relyea's early
findings suggest that today's acceptable levels of pesticides might be far
more deadly to amphibians -- and might pose a greater threat to human
health -- than once thought.


His research also is helping to unravel a mystery that has baffled
scientists for years: Why are frogs around the world disappearing in record
numbers, and is this a harbinger of environmental doom?

Relyea, 38, of Zelienople, Butler County, grew up in Upstate New York and
credits fishing trips with his dad and boyhood forays into muddy ponds for
giving him an early course in biology. It's little wonder that he ended up
with a doctorate in aquatic ecology and an insatiable curiosity about how
nature works.

Five years ago, on a scientific whim, Relyea and a colleague decided to
find out what would happen if they exposed tadpoles to low doses of a
common pesticide called carbaryl (pronounced CARB-a-rill) in the presence
of a predator.

You can buy carbaryl in your local hardware store as the brand-name product
Sevin. And people do -- in droves. Ten to 15 million pounds of this nerve
agent are used every year on farms and in homes across America to keep
crops bug-free and fleas off the family dog. Carbaryl represents one of
about 21,000 chemical pesticides in a multibillion-dollar industry.

Pesticide manufacturers are required to measure the toxicity of all bug and
weed killers they make, and the results must be approved by the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency. Most toxicology data, however, are
collected under artificial conditions: Researchers slowly add a chemical to
a tank of critters and find out how much is needed to kill half of them
over a period of several days. This is the standard way to test the potency
of a substance, but the procedure might grossly underestimate the dangers
of pesticides by failing to account for the real-world effects of predators
and other natural stressors, Relyea said.

Scent of a predator

At the time of Relyea's initial carbaryl experiment, ecologists knew that
tadpoles use chemical cues to detect when predators are nearby and often
reduce their activity or growth rate when they sense danger. But no one had
ever studied what happens when tadpoles, already scared by the "scent" of a
predator, are then treated with supposedly nonlethal amounts of pesticide.

The results were shocking. So shocking, in fact, that Relyea repeated the
experiment before he believed what he saw: Lots and lots of dead tadpoles.

"I said to myself, 'Holy mackerel! These guys are all dead. That wasn't
supposed to happen,'" said Relyea, who had expected his ill-fated tadpoles
to stop growing and become sluggish, at worst.

With further experimentation, Relyea found that low, so-called safe
concentrations of carbaryl are up to 46 times more deadly to tadpoles when
combined with another stressor, the presence of a hungry predator.

The implications of these findings were at once clear, if not conclusive.

"What we thought were safe concentrations of pesticides under some
conditions for some species might not be," Relyea said, choosing his words
carefully for now because there is still a lot of work to be done.

Not glamourous work

Relyea's landmark discovery was published in 2001 in the prestigious and
widely cited Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

Since then, Relyea and his team of graduate students at Pymatuning have
observed the same double-whammy effect of pesticides and predators in a
number of frog species native to North America.

Scientists at the EPA and in the agrichemical industry are taking notice of
these studies, which were the first to bring toxicology out of the lab and
into the field, said Yale University biology professor David Skelly, who
also studies amphibians.

"Dr. Relyea's work has received a lot of attention from people who are
involved in the creation and regulation of pesticides," Skelly said. "They
know that this is going on, and they recognize that it might be really
important."

Important, maybe, but not glamorous.

Days at The Farm are spent hunting for frog eggs in soggy wetlands abuzz
with mosquitoes, capturing larval dragonflies and scrubbing giant cattle
troughs used as tadpole tanks. Ratty T-shirts and hip-waders are the
outfits of choice. With Relyea standing ankle-deep in mud, encircled by
tubs teeming with slimy creatures, it may be hard to believe the science
being done here could trigger a paradigm shift.

"It's still pretty early, and there's going to need to be many more
studies," Skelly said. "But this could represent a fundamental change in
how our society thinks about pesticide safety."

For that to happen, more evidence must be collected pointing toward the
joint effects of pesticides and natural stressors, Skelly said. Research
that links these effects to human health could prompt the EPA and pesticide
industry to re-evaluate how they test the chemicals released into the
environment, he said.

Hopping away

Then there's the enigma of the vanishing frogs.

About a decade ago, scientists realized that amphibian populations around
the world were in decline.

The most important reason for this trend is habitat loss resulting from
draining wetlands and harvesting timber.

But frogs are disappearing in seemingly pristine areas, too, and no one is
quite sure why.

Relyea's experiments suggest that low concentrations of pesticides at work
in natural conditions could be a prime suspect, which in turn would be an
indicator of more widespread water quality problems.

This hypothesis is supported by recent findings of declining amphibian
populations upwind from agricultural lands in central California, Relyea
said. Amphibians collected from this region have decreased amounts of an
enzyme found in the nervous system, evidence that neurotoxins such as
carbaryl are at work, he said.

Back on The Farm, every trough scoured and tadpole hatched in this remote
corner of northwest Pennsylvania could bring Relyea one step closer to
finding answers to these global questions. Along the way, the scientific
pioneer is having the time of his life.

"It's hard to believe we get paid to do this every day," said Relyea,
looking out across his soggy outdoor lab -- the "Ecology Factory" as Skelly
calls it.

"It's just too fun," he said.


--

Nancy Alderman, President
Environment and Human Health, Inc.
1191 Ridge Rd.
North Haven, CT 06473
203-248-6582   (fax) 203 288-7571
http://www.ehhi.org




Reply via email to