OK, I'm not an Alaskan herper, so don't know wood frogs.  We have a number of 
amphibian species in Nevada, including Columbia Spotted Frogs, Pacific Chorus 
Frogs, and Western Toads.  This guy looks toady to me - the back legs are 
relatively short and the toes, which are fairly clear one of his hind feet, 
don't look like the wood frog images I saw on CalPhotos 
http://elib.cs.berkeley.edu/cgi/img_query?enlarge=1111+1111+2222+0087, nor like 
the spotted frog hind feet on CalPhotos (R. luteiventris & R. pretiosa).  The 
toes on those photos are long and narrow, whereas the rear toes on the Alaska 
photo are shorter and broader, and, well, look more "toady" to me.  Also, ranid 
frogs have webbed hind feet (which is clear in some of the CalPhotos) and this 
one's right rear foot has no webbing. To me the spots look raised and look like 
spots we see on Bufo boreas (although the spots also are similar to those on 
some images of spotted frogs).  Although you usually see a light dorsal stripe 
on Bufo boreas, it isn't always present, especially on juveniles and also in an 
underwater shot it may be harder to see. There IS a faint mid-dorsal lightness. 
 Also, the face is rather rounded from what I can see, as a toad's would be, 
and I see no hint of a dorso-lateral fold.
 
On our webpage I've put a NV amphibian guide 
http://www.ndow.org/wild/animals/facts/nvfrogs_toads.pdf that might be of 
interest.  Bufo boreas subspecies have different spot shapes and spot 
distribution; the image on the guide doesn't show the spots that I've seen that 
look most similar to to the Alaska amphibian image.
 
I've put some images on a Yahoo photo website for comparison; if you're 
interested I could send you an "invite" to look at them.  However, most of them 
are from the Calphotos website, so going there would serve the same purpose.  
The Bufo boreas links have quite a few photos, as do the R. luteiventris and R. 
pretiosa links..  B. boreas subspecies (and probably populations) have spotting 
color and distribution variations, but in some areas these red spots 
predominate.
 
I don't consider myself an expert at all, but this provides food for thought.  
The characteristics that most influence my thinking this one looks "toady" are 
the lack of webbing on the hind foot that's clear and visible, the relatively 
shorter legs and toes, lack of a dorsolateral fold, and the rounded face.
 
Anita Shaul (formerly Cook)
Nevada Department of Wildlife
Reno, NV.  89512
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

________________________________

From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] on behalf of Lance Lerum
Sent: Tue 1/11/2005 10:19 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: [akherps] frog ID help



Hi all,
I need your help with the identification of this frog.
(Embedded image moved to file: pic00366.jpg)


I know this is a really poor photo but all that I have.   Our wilderness
rangers (who are off traveling somewhere for the winter) located this frog
August 27, 2004 and at the time, based upon the location and range maps, we
figured they probably had located a wood frog.  In looking through their
reports and looking at this photo closely I am now wondering if that
identification may be in error.  Based upon the lack of a ventral stripe,
the light center spots, and patterns on the legs I am wondering if this
might not be a spotted frog.  The animal in the photo is underwater and the
angle is pretty vertical.  They never did capture the animal and describe
it as "itty-bitty" so I'm thinking it is probably a juvenile; I'll try to
get a better estimate of size when I am able to contact them again.  This
frog was found in Endicott River Wilderness in habitat described as
"glacial swamp" (glacial floodplain, scrub willow, "very cold water"),
(Embedded image moved to file: pic02570.jpg)NAD27AK.
If it is a spotted frog I believe this would be a pretty significant range
extension since it is far from a large mainland river in the middle of the
Chilkat Range.

What do you think?

Lance Lerum,  Ecologist
Admiralty National Monument
8461 Old Dairy Road
Juneau, Ak 99801
voice: 907-790-7479,  fax: 907-586-8795 

<<winmail.dat>>

Reply via email to