hi, in my test system I have 2 processors, A, and B. In the logs below 
reflects this message flow:

*Send persistent message DoDepositCash to A*
*Send persistent message DoSubmitOrder to A,*
*A receives DoSubmitOrder message and yields OrderCashLocked to a channel X 
and delivers to B*
*B receives OrderCashLocked message and yields OrderSubmitted to a channel 
Y and delivers back to A.*

Below are logs printed when the system is initially up:

Processor A @seq=1 
PersistentImpl(DoDepositCash(1878387908787379106,Btc,10000),1,mysys_ap,false,Collections(),Actor[akka.tcp://[email protected]:46804/temp/$e])
Processor A @seq=2 
PersistentImpl(DoSubmitOrder(MarketSide(Btc,Rmb),Order(1878387908787379106,1395212275401,2000,Some(500.0),None,None)),2,mysys_ap,false,Collections(),Actor[akka.tcp://[email protected]:46804/temp/$j])

Processor B->A @seq=1 
ConfirmablePersistentImpl(OrderCashLocked(MarketSide(Btc,Rmb),Order(1878387908787379106,1,2000,Some(500.0),None,None)),1,mysys_mp_btc_rmb,false,0,Collections(),DeliveredByPersistentChannel(X,2,1,Actor[akka://mysys/user/X/$a#1241560331]),Actor[akka://mysys/system/deletion-batch-layer#940984408],Actor[akka.tcp://[email protected]:46804/temp/$j])
Processor A->B @seq=3 
ConfirmablePersistentImpl(OrderSubmitted(OrderInfo(MarketSide(Btc,Rmb),Order(1878387908787379106,1,2000,Some(500.0),None,Some(1395212230304)),0,0,Pending,None),List()),3,mysys_ap,false,0,Collections(),DeliveredByPersistentChannel(Y,1,1,Actor[akka://mysys/user/Y/$a#1653209817]),Actor[akka://mysys/system/deletion-batch-layer#940984408],Actor[akka://mysys/user/market_processor_btc_rmb/singleton#1752194582])

Then I got those during the first replay (no snapshoting):

Processor A @seq=1 
PersistentImpl(DoDepositCash(1878387908787379106,Btc,10000),1,mysys_ap,false,List(),Actor[akka.tcp://[email protected]:46804/temp/$e])
Processor A @seq=2 
PersistentImpl(DoSubmitOrder(MarketSide(Btc,Rmb),Order(1878387908787379106,1395212275401,2000,Some(500.0),None,None)),2,mysys_ap,false,List(X),Actor[akka.tcp://[email protected]:46804/temp/$j])

Processor B->A @seq=1 
ConfirmablePersistentImpl(OrderCashLocked(MarketSide(Btc,Rmb),Order(1878387908787379106,1,2000,Some(500.0),None,None)),1,mysys_mp_btc_rmb,false,0,List(Y),null,null,Actor[akka.tcp://[email protected]:46804/temp/$j])
Processor A->B @seq=3 
ConfirmablePersistentImpl(OrderSubmitted(OrderInfo(MarketSide(Btc,Rmb),Order(1878387908787379106,1,2000,Some(500.0),None,Some(1395212230304)),0,0,Pending,None),List()),3,mysys_ap,false,0,List(),null,null,Actor[akka.tcp://[email protected]:50354/user/market_processor_btc_rmb/singleton#1752194582])

Processor B->A @seq=2 
ConfirmablePersistentImpl(OrderCashLocked(MarketSide(Btc,Rmb),Order(1878387908787379106,1,2000,Some(500.0),None,None)),2,mysys_mp_btc_rmb,false,0,Collections(),DeliveredByPersistentChannel(X,2,1,Actor[akka://mysys/user/X/$a#669702344]),Actor[akka://mysys/system/deletion-batch-layer#1382334128],Actor[akka.tcp://[email protected]:46804/temp/$j])
Processor A->B @seq=4 
ConfirmablePersistentImpl(OrderSubmitted(OrderInfo(MarketSide(Btc,Rmb),Order(1878387908787379106,1,2000,Some(500.0),None,Some(1395212250415)),0,0,Pending,None),List()),4,mysys_ap,false,0,Collections(),DeliveredByPersistentChannel(Y,2,1,Actor[akka://mysys/user/Y/$a#-117955869]),Actor[akka://mysys/system/deletion-batch-layer#1382334128],Actor[akka://mysys/user/market_processor_btc_rmb/singleton#288803418])


And these during 2nd reply:
Processor A @seq=1 
PersistentImpl(DoDepositCash(1878387908787379106,Btc,10000),1,mysys_ap,false,List(),Actor[akka.tcp://[email protected]:46804/temp/$e])
Processor A @seq=2 
PersistentImpl(DoSubmitOrder(MarketSide(Btc,Rmb),Order(1878387908787379106,1395212275401,2000,Some(500.0),None,None)),2,mysys_ap,false,List(X),Actor[akka.tcp://[email protected]:46804/temp/$j])

Processor B->A @seq=1 
ConfirmablePersistentImpl(OrderCashLocked(MarketSide(Btc,Rmb),Order(1878387908787379106,1,2000,Some(500.0),None,None)),1,mysys_mp_btc_rmb,false,0,List(Y),null,null,Actor[akka.tcp://[email protected]:46804/temp/$j])
Processor A->B @seq=3
  
ConfirmablePersistentImpl(OrderSubmitted(OrderInfo(MarketSide(Btc,Rmb),Order(1878387908787379106,1,2000,Some(500.0),None,Some(1395212230304)),0,0,Pending,None),List()),3,mysys_ap,false,0,List(),null,null,Actor[akka.tcp://[email protected]:50354/user/market_processor_btc_rmb/singleton#1752194582])

Processor B->A @seq=2 
ConfirmablePersistentImpl(OrderCashLocked(MarketSide(Btc,Rmb),Order(1878387908787379106,1,2000,Some(500.0),None,None)),2,mysys_mp_btc_rmb,false,0,List(Y),null,null,Actor[akka.tcp://[email protected]:46804/temp/$j])
Processor A->B @seq=4 
ConfirmablePersistentImpl(OrderSubmitted(OrderInfo(MarketSide(Btc,Rmb),Order(1878387908787379106,1,2000,Some(500.0),None,Some(1395212250415)),0,0,Pending,None),List()),4,mysys_ap,false,0,List(),null,null,Actor[akka.tcp://[email protected]:50364/user/market_processor_btc_rmb/singleton#288803418])

Processor B->A @seq=3 
ConfirmablePersistentImpl(OrderCashLocked(MarketSide(Btc,Rmb),Order(1878387908787379106,1,2000,Some(500.0),None,None)),3,mysys_mp_btc_rmb,false,0,Collections(),DeliveredByPersistentChannel(X,2,1,Actor[akka://mysys/user/X/$a#1805531495]),Actor[akka://mysys/system/deletion-batch-layer#138777156],Actor[akka.tcp://[email protected]:46804/temp/$j])
Processor A->B @seq=5 
ConfirmablePersistentImpl(OrderSubmitted(OrderInfo(MarketSide(Btc,Rmb),Order(1878387908787379106,1,2000,Some(500.0),None,Some(1395212250415)),0,0,Pending,None),List()),5,mysys_ap,false,0,Collections(),DeliveredByPersistentChannel(Y,2,1,Actor[akka://mysys/user/Y/$a#-1683723611]),Actor[akka://mysys/system/deletion-batch-layer#138777156],Actor[akka.tcp://[email protected]:50364/user/market_processor_btc_rmb/singleton#288803418])


It seems the processors tied to deliver the same messages to channels but 
channels assigned different sequence numbers to the messages so each reply 
we got additional 2 ConfirmableConsistent messages. I tried different 
journal plugin the results are the same. *Is this a potential bug, or 
something I did wrong?*

FYI, here is how I send the message in code in Processor A:

    case p @ Persistent(DoSubmitOrder(side: MarketSide, order @ 
Order(userId, _, quantity, _, _, _)), seq) =>
      println("--------::::" + seq + " " + p)
          ....
          channelToMarketProcessors ! /* forward */ 
Deliver(p.withPayload(OrderCashLocked(side, o)), getProcessorRef(side))
           ....
      }

   case p @ ConfirmablePersistent(OrderSubmitted(originOrderInfo, txs), 
seq, _) =>

      p.confirm()


and in Processor B: 

case p @ ConfirmablePersistent(OrderCashLocked(side, order: Order), seq, _) 
=>

      val orderSubmitted = ...

      channelToAccountProcessor ! Deliver(p.withPayload(orderSubmitted), 
accountProcessorPath)

      p.confirm()

-- 
>>>>>>>>>>      Read the docs: http://akka.io/docs/
>>>>>>>>>>      Check the FAQ: 
>>>>>>>>>> http://doc.akka.io/docs/akka/current/additional/faq.html
>>>>>>>>>>      Search the archives: https://groups.google.com/group/akka-user
--- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Akka 
User List" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
Visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/akka-user.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

Reply via email to