->>In response to your message<<-
--received from Dustin J. Mitchell--
>
> On Tue, May 27, 2008 at 6:33 PM, Paul Yeatman
> <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> > So then I recompiled the client for both --with-bsdudp-security and
> > --with-bsdtcp-security and loaded both plists. The server was still
> > unable to connect in any way to the client.
> >
> > Then I realized the problem was with my Red Hat Enterprise amanda
> > server which uses its stable albeit older version (2.4.4p3) of AMANDA
> > and one which does not use the new bsdtcp authentication. So, I then
> > went about recompiling AMANDA on the server side as well using the
> > latest 2.6.0p1 version compiling with both --with-bsdudp-security and
> > --with-bsdtcp-security. I wanted to leave both options open but
> > possibly it is conflicting to use both.
>
> Nope -- they can coexist with no problem.
>
> > I'm still not sure on this. I
> > still could make no connection with the client. So then I recompiled
> > the server to use only bsdtcp authentication and I could FINALLY
> > connect with the client yet with the following error message
> >
> > "client configured for auth=bsdudp while server requested 'bsd'"
>
> This is the key. You'll need to add
> auth "bsdtcp"
> to the dumptypes you're using (probably easiest to just add it to the
> global dumptype).
Okay, I have added this.
I have not been able to make the connection work between server and
client without having compiled the client for both bsdtcp AND bsdudp
security. If I use bsdtcp alone, the server never connects to the
client. If I add the 'auth "bsdtcp" to the dumptypes file on the
server, recompile the client for both bsdudp and bsdtcp and load both
plist files on the client (bsdudp only because I have to), things
connect but I get
ERROR: cass74: [client configured for auth=bsdudp while server requested 'BSD']
ERROR: cass74: [client configured for auth=bsdudp while server requested
'bsdtcp']
ERROR: cass74: [client configured for auth=bsdudp while server requested
'bsdtcp']
ERROR: cass74: [client configured for auth=bsdudp while server requested
'bsdtcp']
ERROR: cass74: [client configured for auth=bsdudp while server requested
'bsdtcp']
Yes, all 5 messages. Why does it think the client is "configured for
auth=bsdudp"? I'm only compiling for bsdudp and also loading its plist
file because it won't connect at all without it. I don't know how I
have "configured" the client for bsdudp, however. Only made it a
possibility.
I'll attach the amandad log file from the client.
Paul
1212001824.917179: amandad: pid 90599 ruid 5000 euid 5000: start at Wed May 28
12:10:24 2008
1212001824.917447: amandad: warning: errors processing config file
"/private/etc/amanda/amanda-client.conf" (non-fatal)
1212001824.917762: amandad: security_getdriver(name=bsdudp) returns 0xb4940
1212001824.917790: amandad: version 2.6.0p1
1212001824.917798: amandad: build: VERSION="Amanda-2.6.0p1"
1212001824.917803: amandad: BUILT_DATE="Wed May 28 12:05:53 PDT 2008"
1212001824.917808: amandad: BUILT_MACH="i386-apple-darwin9.2.2"
BUILT_REV="1019"
1212001824.917814: amandad: BUILT_BRANCH="amanda-260" CC="gcc"
1212001824.917819: amandad: paths: bindir="/usr/local/bin"
sbindir="/usr/local/sbin"
1212001824.917824: amandad: libexecdir="/usr/local/libexec"
1212001824.917829: amandad: amlibexecdir="/usr/local/libexec"
1212001824.917834: amandad: mandir="/usr/local/share/man"
1212001824.917839: amandad: AMANDA_TMPDIR="/private/tmp/amanda"
1212001824.917844: amandad: AMANDA_DBGDIR="/private/tmp/amanda"
1212001824.917850: amandad: CONFIG_DIR="/private/etc/amanda"
DEV_PREFIX="/dev/"
1212001824.917855: amandad: RDEV_PREFIX="/dev/r" DUMP="/sbin/dump"
1212001824.917860: amandad: RESTORE="/sbin/restore" VDUMP=UNDEF
VRESTORE=UNDEF
1212001824.917865: amandad: XFSDUMP=UNDEF XFSRESTORE=UNDEF
VXDUMP=UNDEF VXRESTORE=UNDEF
1212001824.917870: amandad: SAMBA_CLIENT="/usr/bin/smbclient"
GNUTAR="/usr/bin/tar"
1212001824.917875: amandad: COMPRESS_PATH="/usr/bin/gzip"
1212001824.917881: amandad: UNCOMPRESS_PATH="/usr/bin/gzip"
LPRCMD="/usr/bin/lpr"
1212001824.917886: amandad: MAILER="/usr/bin/Mail"
1212001824.917891: amandad:
listed_incr_dir="/Users/amanda/gnutar-lists"
1212001824.917896: amandad: defs: DEFAULT_SERVER="cass251"
DEFAULT_CONFIG="laptops"
1212001824.917901: amandad: DEFAULT_TAPE_SERVER="cass251"
1212001824.917906: amandad: DEFAULT_TAPE_DEVICE="file:/etc/laptops"
HAVE_MMAP
1212001824.917912: amandad: NEED_STRSTR HAVE_SYSVSHM
LOCKING=**NONE** SETPGRP_VOID
1212001824.917917: amandad: AMANDA_DEBUG_DAYS=4 BSD_SECURITY
USE_AMANDAHOSTS
1212001824.917922: amandad: CLIENT_LOGIN="amanda" CHECK_USERID
HAVE_GZIP
1212001824.917927: amandad: COMPRESS_SUFFIX=".gz"
COMPRESS_FAST_OPT="--fast"
1212001824.917932: amandad: COMPRESS_BEST_OPT="--best"
UNCOMPRESS_OPT="-dc"
1212001824.917974: amandad: dgram_recv(dgram=0xda204, timeout=0,
fromaddr=0xea1f0)
1212001824.918021: amandad: (sockaddr_in *)0xea1f0 = { 2, 576, 132.239.146.251 }
1212001824.918057: amandad: security_handleinit(handle=0x407ce0, driver=0xb4940
(BSDUDP))
1212001824.921269: amandad: pw_uid-A: 5000
1212001824.921284: amandad: pw_uid-B: 5000
1212001824.921359: amandad: pw_uid-C: 5000
1212001824.921380: amandad: pw_uid-D: 5000
1212001824.921437: amandad: accept recv REQ pkt:
<<<<<
SERVICE noop
OPTIONS features=ffffffff9ffeffffffff00;
>>>>>
1212001824.921462: amandad: creating new service: noop
OPTIONS features=ffffffff9ffeffffffff00;
1212001824.922951: amandad: sending ACK pkt:
<<<<<
>>>>>
1212001824.923085: amandad: dgram_send_addr(addr=0x407d00, dgram=0xda204)
1212001824.923095: amandad: (sockaddr_in *)0x407d00 = { 2, 576, 132.239.146.251
}
1212001824.923101: amandad: dgram_send_addr: 0xda204->socket = 0
1212001825.938659: amandad: sending REP pkt:
<<<<<
OPTIONS features=ffffffff9ffeffffffff00;
>>>>>
1212001825.938706: amandad: dgram_send_addr(addr=0x407d00, dgram=0xda204)
1212001825.938723: amandad: (sockaddr_in *)0x407d00 = { 2, 576, 132.239.146.251
}
1212001825.938735: amandad: dgram_send_addr: 0xda204->socket = 0
1212001825.939118: amandad: dgram_recv(dgram=0xda204, timeout=0,
fromaddr=0xea1f0)
1212001825.939170: amandad: (sockaddr_in *)0xea1f0 = { 2, 576, 132.239.146.251 }
1212001825.939255: amandad: received ACK pkt:
<<<<<
>>>>>
1212001825.939460: amandad: security_close(handle=0x407ce0, driver=0xb4940
(BSDUDP))
1212001825.940789: amandad: dgram_recv(dgram=0xda204, timeout=0,
fromaddr=0xea1f0)
1212001825.941007: amandad: (sockaddr_in *)0xea1f0 = { 2, 576, 132.239.146.251 }
1212001825.941064: amandad: security_handleinit(handle=0x407cd0, driver=0xb4940
(BSDUDP))
1212001825.946862: amandad: pw_uid-A: 5000
1212001825.946887: amandad: pw_uid-B: 5000
1212001825.947077: amandad: pw_uid-C: 5000
1212001825.947100: amandad: pw_uid-D: 5000
1212001825.947172: amandad: accept recv REQ pkt:
<<<<<
SERVICE selfcheck
OPTIONS
features=ffffffff9ffeffffffff00;maxdumps=1;hostname=cass74;config=laptops;
GNUTAR /Users 0 OPTIONS
|;auth=BSD;compress-fast;index;exclude-list=/Users/amanda/home.gtar;
GNUTAR /usr/local 0 OPTIONS
|;auth=bsdtcp;compress-fast;index;exclude-list=/Users/amanda/exclude.gtar;
GNUTAR /sw 0 OPTIONS
|;auth=bsdtcp;compress-fast;index;exclude-list=/Users/amanda/exclude.gtar;
GNUTAR /System 0 OPTIONS
|;auth=bsdtcp;compress-fast;index;exclude-list=/Users/amanda/exclude.gtar;
GNUTAR /Applications 0 OPTIONS
|;auth=bsdtcp;compress-fast;index;exclude-list=/Users/amanda/exclude.gtar;
>>>>>
1212001825.947209: amandad: creating new service: selfcheck
OPTIONS
features=ffffffff9ffeffffffff00;maxdumps=1;hostname=cass74;config=laptops;
GNUTAR /Users 0 OPTIONS
|;auth=BSD;compress-fast;index;exclude-list=/Users/amanda/home.gtar;
GNUTAR /usr/local 0 OPTIONS
|;auth=bsdtcp;compress-fast;index;exclude-list=/Users/amanda/exclude.gtar;
GNUTAR /sw 0 OPTIONS
|;auth=bsdtcp;compress-fast;index;exclude-list=/Users/amanda/exclude.gtar;
GNUTAR /System 0 OPTIONS
|;auth=bsdtcp;compress-fast;index;exclude-list=/Users/amanda/exclude.gtar;
GNUTAR /Applications 0 OPTIONS
|;auth=bsdtcp;compress-fast;index;exclude-list=/Users/amanda/exclude.gtar;
1212001825.949239: amandad: sending ACK pkt:
<<<<<
>>>>>
1212001825.949391: amandad: dgram_send_addr(addr=0x407cf0, dgram=0xda204)
1212001825.949406: amandad: (sockaddr_in *)0x407cf0 = { 2, 576, 132.239.146.251
}
1212001825.949417: amandad: dgram_send_addr: 0xda204->socket = 0
could not open conf file "/private/etc/amanda/amanda-client.conf": No such file
or directory
could not open conf file "/private/etc/amanda/laptops/amanda-client.conf": No
such file or directory
ERROR [The auth in the inetd/xinetd configuration must be the same as the DLE]
ERROR [The auth in the inetd/xinetd configuration must be the same as the DLE]
ERROR [The auth in the inetd/xinetd configuration must be the same as the DLE]
ERROR [The auth in the inetd/xinetd configuration must be the same as the DLE]
ERROR [The auth in the inetd/xinetd configuration must be the same as the DLE]
1212001826.978116: amandad: sending REP pkt:
<<<<<
OPTIONS features=ffffffff9ffeffffffff00;
ERROR [client configured for auth=bsdudp while server requested 'BSD']
OK /Users
OK /Users
OK /Users
ERROR [client configured for auth=bsdudp while server requested 'bsdtcp']
OK /usr/local
OK /usr/local
OK /usr/local
ERROR [client configured for auth=bsdudp while server requested 'bsdtcp']
ERROR [Could not access /sw (/sw): No such file or directory]
ERROR [client configured for auth=bsdudp while server requested 'bsdtcp']
OK /System
OK /System
OK /System
ERROR [client configured for auth=bsdudp while server requested 'bsdtcp']
OK /Applications
OK /Applications
OK /Applications
OK /usr/local/libexec/runtar executable
OK /usr/bin/tar executable
OK /Users/amanda/gnutar-lists/. read/writable
ERROR [can not read/write /Users/amanda/amandates: No such file or directory]
OK /usr/bin/gzip executable
OK /dev/null read/writable
OK /private/tmp/amanda has more than 64KB available.
OK /private/tmp/amanda has more than 64KB available.
OK /etc has more than 64KB available.
>>>>>
1212001826.978193: amandad: dgram_send_addr(addr=0x407cf0, dgram=0xda204)
1212001826.978218: amandad: (sockaddr_in *)0x407cf0 = { 2, 576, 132.239.146.251
}
1212001826.978237: amandad: dgram_send_addr: 0xda204->socket = 0
1212001826.978813: amandad: dgram_recv(dgram=0xda204, timeout=0,
fromaddr=0xea1f0)
1212001826.978867: amandad: (sockaddr_in *)0xea1f0 = { 2, 576, 132.239.146.251 }
1212001826.978972: amandad: received ACK pkt:
<<<<<
>>>>>
1212001826.979250: amandad: security_close(handle=0x407cd0, driver=0xb4940
(BSDUDP))
1212001854.979684: amandad: pid 90599 finish time Wed May 28 12:10:54 2008
