On 27/06/2010 15:58, David Jencks wrote: > <mentor>Are you sure you want to continue this discussion with a vote at this > point? It's OK to have votes about anything you want :-) but.... they tend > to be polarizing and end up with a losing side who may not be happy. I think > that trying to get a consensus on design decisions through discussion is > often a better route.</mentor> > > <interested party> I don't understand the details of this proposal. Could > someone come up with a realistic example showing how the "same" OAuth message > would be sent using annotations, and not using annotations, and what would > happen internally to this information? It might be obvious to anyone who > knows anything about oauth but would help me out a lot </interested party>
What form would you like the example in, pseudo-code or written description? p > thanks > david jencks > > On Jun 25, 2010, at 7:55 AM, Simone Tripodi wrote: > >> Hi all, >> I'm here to call a new vote to define our design direction. Some >> threads ago on this ML, Pid and I were discussing about the use, or >> not, of Java metadata Annotations to enhance OAuth messages and >> tokens. >> >> Pros: >> * marshallers/unmarshallers to/from strings could be auto-generated >> using the APT; >> * the calculation of the base string (just an example) is parameter agnostic. >> >> Cons: >> * not so hard writing parsers (JavaCC? AntLR? XText?) and serializers; >> * not so hard writing the base string algorithm >> >> So please cast your votes in favor of >> >> [] Pro Annotations >> [] Cons Annotations >> >> The vote will stay open for the next 72 hours. It would be nice if the >> choice comes with a justification, so everybody can take care about >> someone else's considerations. >> >> My vote if >> >> [X] Pro Annotations >> >> I already implemented the base string calculus based only on metadata >> discovery and I didn't take care about the parameter retrieving >> criteria. I'd love to have a choice to see Annotations in action on >> compile-time :P >> >> Cheers, have a nice weekend, >> Simo >> >> http://people.apache.org/~simonetripodi/ >> http://www.99soft.org/ >
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
