----- Mail original ----- > De: "Brian Goetz" <brian.go...@oracle.com> > À: "amber-spec-experts" <amber-spec-experts@openjdk.java.net> > Envoyé: Jeudi 17 Janvier 2019 17:26:06 > Objet: break-with
>> Being able to call this something like `break-with v` (or some other derived >> keyword) would have made this all a lot simpler. (BTW, we can still do this, >> since expression-switch is still in preview.) > > It seems we’re all in favor of break-with over unadorned “break”? > > Which feeds into the bigger question about promoting expression switch to > final > in 13. I don’t think this syntactic change on its own merits re-previewing > the > feature; this is exactly the sort of “feature is finished, but we might change > the paint color based on feedback” kind of thing that the preview mechanism > was > intended for. > > We don’t have to make this decision quite yet, but sometime between now and > feature-freeze for 13 (June) we have to take one of the following actions: > > - File a JEP to make it a permanent feature, possibly with changes > - File a JEP to re-preview it, possibly with changes > - Withdraw the feature > > We can continue to gather feedback on the feature and revisit later. Like last year, i (with José Paumar) will run a poll at Devoxx France (17th to 19th of April) on the expression switch, i can ask if it should be included permanently, still in preview or withdrawn and post the result on this list. Rémi
