Hi All, It's time to close the vote on the "Release Amdatu Platform 1.0.0". The results:
+1 binding: Marcel Offermans, Jan-Willem Janssen, Hans Bossenbroek -1 binding : Ivo Ladage So the vote failed. Thanks to Ivo's testing and feedback we've identified a couple off blocking issues[0] and are in the process off fixing them. Once these are resolved we will release RC2 and call a new vote. Regards, Bram [0] http://jira.amdatu.org/jira/browse/AMDATU-675 On Mon, May 14, 2012 at 9:41 AM, Bram de Kruijff <[email protected]> wrote: > Hi Ivo, > > On Fri, May 11, 2012 at 5:06 PM, Ivo Ladage-van Doorn > <[email protected]> wrote: >> Hi All, >> >> Today I have continued (with help from Bram) the work on upgrading the Auth, >> OpenSocial and Cassandra subprojects to 1.0.0-RC1. The good news is that I >> finally succeeded to get it all up and running, provisioned by the AMS >> (there are still some issues though). Seeing it actually work is pretty cool >> ;-> >> The bad news is that it was not that simple. I ran into several issues I >> think should be resolved before we can formally release 1.0. These issues >> are: >> >> http://jira.amdatu.org/jira/browse/AMDATU-669 >> There seems to be no proper solution yet for creating a bundle containing >> servlets that are not multi-tenant > > There are 2 solutions listed here and I have create a feature request > under AMDATU-674. I'm not convinced we should block on a possible > improvement. The specific use case is covered and you can achieve your > goal without much trouble, right? > >> http://jira.amdatu.org/jira/browse/AMDATU-673 >> Kitchensink web demo doesn't seem to work and still contains 0.4.0 artifacts > > Can't reproduce and possibly related to a deployment issue. See the > update and please retry. > >> http://jira.amdatu.org/jira/browse/AMDATU-649 >> itest artifacts are not released, so I cannot create integration tests for >> the subprojects anymore > > The itests are no part of the release. As I said in the issue this is > on purpose and there is nothing to prevent you from depending on a > (fixed) snapshot. We will release them separately soon to allow > projects to depend on them. > >> http://jira.amdatu.org/jira/browse/AMDATUMNGMNT-10 >> Removing a tenant doesn't seem to work >> >> http://jira.amdatu.org/jira/browse/AMDATUMNGMNT-11 >> Tenant services 'disappear' when the AMA is restarted. > > These are indeed serious issues. Haven't had time to dive into them yet. > >> Bram did also run into AMDATU-571 with 1.0.0-RC1 once (but could not >> reproduce it, so did not (yet) reopen it). > > True > >> So for that reason, I vote -1. > > Fair enough > >> >> Furthermore I think the development tools for the provisioning situation >> need attention (if not in 1.0, it should be on the short term roadmap). A >> simple bundle or configuration update from a maven project can be quite a >> struggle when using the AMS. Issues like AMDATUMNGMNT-8 are very annoying >> for developers. >> I would also like to see AMDATU-659 resolved. In the new multi-tenant design >> it can be quite a struggle to find out why certain services do not start, >> the 'dm notavail' command is therefore crucial for me but each bundle update >> breaks it. > > I agree we can improve a lot in that area so keep the feedback coming > ;) Keep in mind though that we're not pretending this is a full > fledged developer sdk. You have the APIs, the tools and the code to > easily address these issues. > > greets, > Bram > > >> Regards, Ivo >> >> -----Original Message----- >> From: [email protected] >> [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Bram de Kruijff >> Sent: donderdag 10 mei 2012 14:12 >> To: [email protected]; [email protected] >> Subject: [Amdatu-users] [VOTE] Release Amdatu Platform 1.0.0 >> >> Hi all, >> >> based on the annouced 1.0.0-RC1 we would like to start a vote on the release >> fore Amdatu Platform 1.0.0 along with the Amdatu MgmtServer 1.0.0 and Amdatu >> Kitchensink 1.0.0. >> >> Please take some time to review the code/artifacts/docs etc and lets us know >> if you think we are ready for release. >> >> As this is the first vote on this major release we'll keep this vote open >> until 8PM CEST Wed May 16, 2012 >> >> [ ] +1 Approve the release >> [ ] -1 Veto the release (please provide specific comments) >> >> List of artifacts, including sources and javadoc, in the release are >> downloadable from the repository. Here's a list of what is in this release: >> >> org/amdatu/ace/org.amdatu.ace.client/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/configadmin/org.amdatu.configadmin/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/configadmin/org.amdatu.multitenant.org.apache.felix.configadmin/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/deployment/org.amdatu.deployment/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/deployment/org.amdatu.deployment.autoconf/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/eventadmin/org.amdatu.eventadmin/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/eventadmin/org.amdatu.multitenant.org.apache.felix.eventadmin/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/fileinstall/org.amdatu.fileinstall/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/fileinstall/org.amdatu.fileinstall.autoconf/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/fileinstall/org.amdatu.fileinstall.tenantconf/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/httpservice/org.amdatu.httpservice/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/httpservice/org.amdatu.multitenant.org.apache.felix.http.jetty/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/kitchensink/org.amdatu.kitchensink/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/kitchensink/org.amdatu.kitchensink.demo.tenant.global/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/kitchensink/org.amdatu.kitchensink.demo.tenant.local/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/kitchensink/org.amdatu.kitchensink.demo.tenant.web/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/kitchensink/org.amdatu.kitchensink.release/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/logservice/org.amdatu.logservice/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/logservice/org.amdatu.multitenant.org.apache.felix.log/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/maven/org.amdatu.maven.plugin/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/mgmtserver/org.amdatu.mgmtserver/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/osgisupport/org.amdatu.osgisupport/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/preferences/org.amdatu.multitenant.org.apache.felix.prefs/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/preferences/org.amdatu.preferences/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/release/org.amdatu.release/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/template/org.amdatu.template/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/template/org.amdatu.template.processor/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/tenant/org.amdatu.tenant/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/tenant/org.amdatu.tenant.adapter/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/tenant/org.amdatu.tenant.api/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/tenant/org.amdatu.tenant.conf.configadmin/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/tenant/org.amdatu.tenant.conf.rp/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/tenant/org.amdatu.tenantconf.rp.helper/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/tenant/org.amdatu.tenant.factory/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/useradmin/org.amdatu.multitenant.org.amdatu.useradmin.pax.fsstorage/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/useradmin/org.amdatu.multitenant.org.ops4j.pax.useradmin.pax-useradmin-provider-preferences/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/useradmin/org.amdatu.multitenant.org.ops4j.pax.useradmin.pax-useradmin-service/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/useradmin/org.amdatu.useradmin/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/useradmin/org.amdatu.useradmin.pax.fsstorage/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/web/org.amdatu.web/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/web/org.amdatu.web.dispatcher/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/web/org.amdatu.web.httpcontext/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/web/org.amdatu.web.jaxrs/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/web/org.amdatu.web.jsp/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/web/org.amdatu.web.resource/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/web/org.amdatu.web.tenantresolver.hostname/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/web/org.amdatu.web.tenantresolver.parameter/1.0.0-RC1 >> org/amdatu/web/org.amdatu.web.wink/1.0.0-RC1 >> >> >> Regards, >> Bram >> _______________________________________________ >> Amdatu-users mailing list >> [email protected] >> http://lists.amdatu.org/mailman/listinfo/amdatu-users >> >> _______________________________________________ >> Amdatu-developers mailing list >> [email protected] >> http://lists.amdatu.org/mailman/listinfo/amdatu-developers _______________________________________________ Amdatu-developers mailing list [email protected] http://lists.amdatu.org/mailman/listinfo/amdatu-developers
